I've learned a few things about "sandbox" campaigns, at least from my side of the table.
First, they work better when players have a few levels (and history of the campaign) behind them. That isn't much of a surprise, as sandboxes are largely player / character driven, and there has to be some history and investment before the desire to spread one's wings with an actual direction takes place. The Saturday night group is about to hit this.
It also requires frequent play and a steady roster. My Friday night group is, by it's intentional design, the exact opposite of this. Once a month more or less, with a changing roster (but pretty much a set core), it is not made for a sandbox. Maybe layer it will evolve into one, but with the slower leveling and the "drop in / drop out" nature of the campaign, I suspect not.
I'm beginning to see how something like Barrowmaze is an ideal adventure location for the "drop in / drop out" style of gaming.
Idle post breakfast thoughts on a rainy Thursday morning...
Thursday, March 20, 2014
My Sandbox Failure - Not a Good Fit For a "Once a Month Drop in / Drop Out" Campaign
Labels:
gaming thoughts
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Tenkar's Tavern is supported by various affiliate programs, including Amazon, RPGNow,
and Humble Bundle as well as Patreon. Your patronage is appreciated and helps keep the
lights on and the taps flowing. Your Humble Bartender, Tenkar
Blogs of Inspiration & Erudition
-
-
Dungeons & Dragons White Box 05 - *Clerics: Clerics gain some of the advantages from both of the other two classes (Fighting-Men and Magic-Users] in that they have the use of magic armor ...1 hour ago
-
October Horror Movie Challenge: Gods of the Deep (2023) - [image: Gods of the Deep (2023)] Tonight's move was another attack of opportunity. My wife doesn't like horror films. She has been wanting to watch some mor...5 hours ago
-
Germanic Test Painting - I've been trying to find a set of pre-mixed paints that I'm satisfied with for painting my 15mm WWII German foot-sloggers and artillerymen. They've almos...6 hours ago
-
The Last Temptation of the DM: Why a Living Breathing World Needs Systematising - Is it possible to create a sandbox that is a 'living, breathing world'? No. It is possible to create one that to all intents and purposes *resembles* suc...17 hours ago
-
OSR Review & Commentary On The Gansu Subsector for The Earth Sector Rpg By Authors John Watts and William Fisher From Independence Games or Your Old School 2d6 Science Fiction Rpg's - " Welcome to the Chinese gate.""Gansu Subsector, Subsector B of Earth Sector, is one of the few subsectors within the sector that is not named for a mythi...1 day ago
-
On Bounty, Questions worth asking. - Well? Will we? Available Now! https://sinlessrpg.com ------------------------------ *Hack & Slash* Follow, Twitch, Support, Donate to end Cancer (5 ...1 day ago
-
Strange Knights - You’ve probably met knights from other realms, but these are different. While they resemble familiar knights in many ways, they have a different oath and...2 days ago
-
Rob Kuntz at Lucca Comics & Games 2025 - If you are planning a trip to Europe (like right now) and wish to catch up with me in person, make sure to book a detour via *Lucca Comics & Games*, ...2 days ago
-
Prismatic Worms (Prismatic Planet) - Did you ever notice how *purple worms* are listed under “P” in the D&D monster manuals, but *red dragons* are under “D”? Not sure where I’ll file my entrie...3 days ago
-
October Horror Movie Challenge - Berberian Sound Studio (2012) - SynopsisBritish sound engineer Gilderoy arrives at the Berberian film studio to work on what he thinks is an equestrian film. Soon his grip on reality sta...3 days ago
-
Jonstown Jottings #101: Spiders Gorge - Much like the Miskatonic Repository for Call of Cthulhu, Seventh Edition, the Jonstown Compendium is a curated platform for user-made content, but for ma...3 days ago
-
Community Greyhawk – The Song of Iara - Today’s community Greyhawk takes us to The Song of Iara, a sequel/expansion of 2019’s Ghosts of Saltmarsh. It’s a 117 page pdf, with a standard 5E interior...3 days ago
-
ChatGPT seems to have opinions about the sort of games I want to play - I've been continuing my experimentation in using AI to code games/game aids by playing around with a character generator for the various threads of gamin...4 days ago
-
The Follow Me, And Die! Kickstarter Is Now Live! - Follow Me, And Die! The Card Game is now Live on Kickstarter! https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1587147156/follow-me-and-die-the-card-game5 days ago
-
The Shrike - By Leo HuntPublished by Joel HinesOSELevel 1? The Shrike is a world of decay – rusted iron, crumbling stone, saltwater, blood, and fog – surrounded by a ro...5 days ago
-
Random Links for 10/10/2025 - - AD&D Asassination. Seems straightforward in the PHB, and then the DMG comes and takes it away. Thanks, Gary. - Next game is in 3 weeks.6 days ago
-
Stonehell: B-Team Meets the Chosen of Zunbar & Rocky - Session 290 was played on 7/27/25 Sonara, Wizard 3 (Rob) Adorellen, Elf 2 (Me) Glimmer, Kobold 3 (Lanse) Kessaren, Cleric 3 (Cindy) Loahn, Halfling 3 (Josh)...6 days ago
-
What is the point of the OSR? - Over on Reddit, Kaliburnus asks What the point of the OSR is? He concludes his post with some questions. So, honest question, what is the point of OSR?...1 week ago
-
Ten Marlinko Townies To Annoy Your Party With - # Name Description 1 Mother Feketa Mummified, animate matriarch who rules her tenement block from a tub of heated mud. Gives quests in exchange for...1 week ago
-
Quick Reviews from Mail Bag - Still waiting on Dolemwood Arrivals: The Caverns of Thracia Yoon-Suin 2nd Ed BX Essentials Ryecroft *The Caverns of Thracia ...1 week ago
-
Tombs: Fantasy Made Mortal... - So Gregorius 21778 has released *The Tomb of Ferkhat the Dreaded* for Blood of Pangea, complete with an excursion into an Egyptian-inspired burial. We lo...1 week ago
-
A review of The Golden Peaches of Samarkand - by Edward H. Schafer tldr; this book has a whole sub-section on Dwarfs Its 1962 and Edward H Schafer delves into ream upon uncounted ream of scholarship ...1 week ago
-
Unboxing the 2025 D&D Starter Set - I grabbed the 2025 Dungeons & Dragons Starter Set at Barnes & Nobles on Friday. An 'undented' copy. Because it is a Starter Set and meant to assist he...2 weeks ago
-
Musings on the OSR Blogosphere and Forums - Link to discussion There are some posts on the historical OSR blog scene that I’ve read recently from the Grumpy … Continue reading →3 weeks ago
-
How do you do piracy… in SPACE!? - Interstellar space travel in Iridium Moons was always going to be a form of hyperspace jump like in Star Wars or Traveller. Simply because it’s the one for...4 weeks ago
-
Free GM Resource: Freep!k Icon Generator - [image: Free GM Resource: Freep!k Icon Generator] Last week I mentioned a *secret project* and while I'm not going to divulge the project yet, I am bringi...4 weeks ago
-
The line has been crossed - I hope all you fuckers enjoyed your Blue Sky. It is coming. You reap what you sow.The right to free speech is a hill I will die upon.Slight update: Anyone...5 weeks ago
-
Zock Bock Radio return engagement - German AD&D superfan and podcast host Settembrini (who already had me on his show a couple-three years back) recently completed a two-year-long run thro...1 month ago
-
Greyhawk News You Can Use - Harvester 2025 Edition - I’m well-overdue for another Greyhawk news roundup, and a recent post by /u/talktoh in /r/Greyhawk prompted me to complete catchup on Greyhawk news for the...1 month ago
-
Against the Starmaster: Playtest materials available - I thought that I would mention that there is a space opera version of *Against the Darkmaster* coming out. It’s called (somewhat unsurprisingly) *Against ...1 month ago
-
Tomb of the Blind and Deaf Dead - So the cat is out of the bag thanks to Tobias Schulte-Krumpen, who posted the above image to the Lamentations of the Flame Princess facebook group. I ...1 month ago
-
Eyes of Idola, Part 2 - This is Part 2. Here is Part 1. *Concept 1: Entering the Dungeon* Descending the stairs into B1, the party reach rooms that are dark, crowded, flooded, a...1 month ago
-
[BLOG] News on the March! Episode X. - This post continues the series of brief play reports I have been posting on Discord. This does not cover every single session (sometimes, recon and setup...2 months ago
-
The First Dungeon Crawl in History - Mapping a Lost Session Report, Part II - Today detailed reports from game sessions are common. Until recently, some of the oldest I knew of were to be found in Alarums & Excursions, but only ra...2 months ago
-
A long overdue hobby update! - Welcome back to the Vault everyone! 2025 is going by in a blur; I last posted in February, almost started a post in March and now it's the end of May. W...4 months ago
-
Pulp: Adventure Location: Trindade & Martim Vaz - History is fractally interesting. Start examine any event, or following any citation, and interesting facts emerge. But some places, for whatever reason,...5 months ago
-
All Work and No D&D Makes Homer Something Something - I have a problem. I haven't played an RPG in about a year. Circumstances in my life are such that I have precious little free time. Now that I've written...5 months ago
-
Playing at the World 2E V2 Arrives - With the release of its second volume, the second edition of *Playing at the World *is finally complete. The two books combined total well over 1,000 ...5 months ago
-
Blogs on Tape season 6 has begun! - Hi everybody! Its been a minute. How are you? Everything is awful all the time? Horrors never cease? You’re being driven mad by the weight of the unfathoma...5 months ago
-
Lexicon of Klarkash-Ton, Hierophant of Atlantis: Lupanar - This time, we follow the good High Priest to the far future, to the final continent of Earth, Zothique, for a a tale of ennui and love: Morthylla. Witho...7 months ago
-
Articulations - Creating house rules, custom rules specific to a local group or campaign, has been common throughout the history of D&D. What makes an effective house rule...9 months ago
-
Writing playlists for all occasions - Hello again! Going off the idea of inspiration elaborated on by the prior post, I also have music playing while I write my various games and fiction pieces...9 months ago
-
The Tarot of Pips - Somewhere in your dice collection is a die like this one, the humblest of dice. Although you don't know it, this small white die carries with it a secr...10 months ago
-
Pirates and Necromancers, a Play Report - Over the Thanksgiving weekend we did a lot of gaming ranging from “off-table” domain level stuff to some solo adventures to spell and magic item rese...10 months ago
-
It's been a bit - Hey everyone, I hope you are doing well! I've had a lot going on and haven't had much time to blog lately. Heres a recap of gaming events and other st...1 year ago
-
*'s in SpaaaaaAaaaace - A lot of SF (including a certain 2D6 RPG grandaddy) deal with ancient aliens taking humans from Earth and dropping them, fleas and all, on one or more w...1 year ago
-
Last move - to self-hosting! - As my vote regarding Substack in the “marketplace of ideas”, I’m moving to self-hosting. I’m now at (and hopefully staying for a long time at) Blog: ht...1 year ago
-
Osamu Tezuka (1928 - 1989) - [image: Osamu Tezuka - Shonen Magazine Cover, 1970]Shonen Magazine Cover, 1970 [image: Osamu Tezuka - Shonen Magazine Cover Illustration 1970]Shonen Maga...3 years ago
-
Clean Your Room - Looking back at my little blog here. That last post… wow, I was having fun playing WOW Classic! That was August of 1999 and I was having a blast… it was ...3 years ago
-
-
Steve Jackson Interview - James Maliszewski recently did an interview with Steve Jackson over on his Grognardia blog. Steve chats about the beginnings of The Fantasy Trip and upcomi...5 years ago
-
The Hero’s Journey 2nd Edition, Campbellian roleplaying at its best! - (this review done using the reviewers own purchased copy) I have been a James Michael Spahn fan since he wrote his Swords & Wizardry Companion. His writing...5 years ago
-
ToAD Monster of the Week: Crocoman - Now that I'm back doing the blog thing I thought I would use Tome of Adventure Design to create monsters for The Black Hack. Using the monster tables in th...5 years ago
-
More Arden Vul Art - Another great piece from Del, this one's the Forum of Set: a place that the PCs may spend quite a bit of time within.5 years ago
-
OCHRE SAND - Init +0 Ranged Atk • fire burst +3 (1d14+1, 20') AC 17 HD 3d6 MV 60 Act 1d24 SP 'breath' weapon, sideslip, perfect silence, morphing Fort +5 Ref +8 Will...5 years ago
-
Strange, Dangerous, and Inhuman: The Fey and Fairie - When I was a boy I loved fairy tales. Jack and the Beanstalk, Puss in Boots, Rumpelstiltskin - I devoured all of it. My fascination that there was a strang...5 years ago
-
The Faithful - An Optional Archetype for Sharp Swords & Sinister Spells Revised Edition - Work on the revised edition of Sharp Swords & Sinister Spells is moving along. This will be a hefty tome, with a LOT of tools and new options to customiz...5 years ago
-
Dungeons & Dragonmead Fall Schedule - *As you know, I run public classic Dungeons & Dragons games at **The Loaded Die**/Metro Detroit Game Night's Board Game Nigh at **Dragonmead**, in Warren...6 years ago
-
Fiction in Airhde - On a whim this weekend, I picked up some fiction off the TLG store. *A Houseless God & Other Tales* and *The Mirrored Soul & Other Tales*, both by the T...6 years ago
-
-
Ravensburg Reboot: Streamlined City Map - I mentioned in my last post how I was tweaking and reworking parts of my Ravensburg setting. Today I streamlined the city map. The old map had lots of redu...6 years ago
-
The Withered Crag available now - I just enabled the sale of the PDF version of The Withered Crag at DriveThruRPG a few minutes ago, and the custom print version will be available startin...6 years ago
-
Annihilation Rising Goes live - The latest in Fail Squad Games’ Quick Kick projects has gone live and needs your support!! This project is only running 11 days and ends on 5/28/2019! ...6 years ago
-
James's Celebration of Life - We could not have asked for a prettier day for James's service. It was a bit chilly and windy but gorgeous. A heartfelt thank you to all that joined us tod...6 years ago
-
Trap Tuesday: A step back - I will get back to Tomb of Horrors soon. I found a topic that was interesting enough to take a break. While interacting in a 5E group on Facebook I talked ...6 years ago
-
Let's Talk About Pacing! - The idea, I think, is that the RPG is ultimately about the long game. Even rolling back to the early days of Basic & Expert, the goal of the player was...6 years ago
-
Profane and Profound Prep Part 2 - This is part 2 of my work to edit my magic items for a DMsGuild release, along with adding cursed items along the way. Here is part 1. Bone of a Saint 8000...6 years ago
-
MIDDLE DUNGEONS LEVEL FIVE 158 STAIRS. - 158 STAIRS. These stairs descend thirty feet to Area 79 on Level 6.6 years ago
-
Please, I don't do paid advertisements - don't ask. - A little note since people have asked me about this. My video channel's *not* an advertising platform, so I'm not available for hire if you want to promote...6 years ago
-
New website! - Slowly but surely, all the content here will make its way — in updated form! — to my new website: timbannock.com. For fairly obvious reasons, that site wil...6 years ago
-
Please Update Your Link! - If you're seeing this, it means your link to the Greyhawk Grognard blog is out of date. Please update your link to www.greyhawkgrognard.com (RSS feed is h...6 years ago
-
Total Sales for WB:FMAG - Hi Folks, It's been a long time since I provided an update for the sales of White Box: Fantastic Medieval Adventure Game. *LULU* Print: 396 PDF: 433 *OBS*...7 years ago
-
How can We Destroy this Campaign World? - d12 1. You must trick a bard into strumming the *Chords of Fate* on the *Lute of Annihilation* 2. Legends tell of thermonuclear weapons beneath megadunge...7 years ago
-
Mord Mar - Session 5 - We had another successful delve into the dungeon yesterday. The delvers: Moira, the Magic-User Radovan - Human Cleric (of Odin?) Khazgar Stonehand - Dwarf ...7 years ago
-
Yodeling For Yokels or The Further Misa(d&)dventures - This is the one of those posts that points out the lack of current posts. Over the last week or three, there has been postponed Labyrinth Lord (twice, one...7 years ago
-
Bundle of Fantasy Age - Bundle of Holding: Dragon Age/Fantasy Age: Available until March 12. PA Presents: Fantasy AGE Freeport live play Green Ronin in 2018 The Fantasy Age RPG ma...7 years ago
-
New Free PDF Module: The Hyqueous Vaults - A new dungeon module—written in celebration of OSRIC's 10th Birthday—by Rebecca Dettmann, Allan T. Grohe, Jr., Jimm Johnson, Matthew Riedel, Alex Zisch, a...7 years ago
-
Session XCIII: One Pissed Off Dragon! - Our ongoing Swords and Wizardry sandbox campaign... *Current Player Characters:* *Thenus* (Ranger) *Wang Du* (Monk) *Wolfheir* (Viking) *Arg* (Half-orc) ...8 years ago
-
Swords & Wizardry Light: Session # 6 - Two months after our last session (thanks to things like 8th grade finals, a 4 year-old's birthday and party, Father's Day, etc.), we finally had our next ...8 years ago
Barrowmaze feels perfect. I really like having some kind of actual in-game reason for the comings and goings - like an "explorer's guild" or some such which puts together expeditions (like say, into the Barrowmaze) and which picks participants from its roster. Any newcomers simply create a guild member, and they're aboard without the need for a lengthy introduction.
ReplyDeleteI think that's true of megadungeons in general. Because of their nature, they work well with a group that might not consist of the same faces week after week. I ran Castle of the Mad Archmage exactly that way and it worked fine (although eventually the group became a more stable roster, and it still worked).
ReplyDeleteWhat Joseph said. My own game is a megadungeon game, and only a "sandbox" in the sense of a real sandbox ("You can play any way you want, within reason, in this very small bounded area.") It's generally the same core but with players who drop in when their schedule permits. We start and end in town so people can swap in and out without explanation beyond "I'm here and ready to go delving."
DeleteHmm. I have some more thoughts on drop-in gaming and I'll go blog them later if I have time. But a notionally pure sandbox isn't one of the things I've gotten going. Rails are better, and a small bounded sandbox works great too.
It should go without saying that we're really enjoying the Friday night games. It's solid fun from beginning to end, and part of it is because we get to just start at the adventure and not have to go looking around for it. Sticking the Friday night guys in front of a megadungeon would be fine. Maybe not Barrowmaze, though - I like it, but if it's (nearly) all undead all the time, it'll get to be a bit of a slog. Plus I read the whole thing a couple times, which won't help my sensawonda at all. :)
Agreed, as far as the level of consistency required to run a good sandbox game. I ran into the same issues a couple of years ago with wanting to run a wide-open sandbox. We had a handful of semi-regular players, but most sessions would be almost half new players, and often those would be new to the game in general. For close to two years now I've used Barrowmaze for those kinds of games- casual games with a motley group of players- and it's worked great. Easy to play at the local bar, and the new players get to be introduced to the dungeon by old players who've made their marks in the past- literally! There's a fair amount of PC-created graffiti in our Barrowmaze and players get really into recognizing the effects of their past actions.
ReplyDeleteMy experience mirrors your at my local game store, Gold Star Anime in Edinboro, PA. I am willing to handle what ever the group decides to do, however with people dropping in and out gaming every two to three weeks, it works better when focused on a tentpole locale, like a forest, megadungeon,etc.
ReplyDeleteThere is a reason why so many of the original sandbox campaigns included a tentpole location for casual play. The widest of wide-open sandboxes still benefits from having one or more places that the players know they can simply go exploring without too much thinking about where to go.
ReplyDeleteWithin those areas, you can then seed hints and clues about what else can be uncovered, leading players to explore additional locations as their desire leads them.
Also, Barrowmaze (! & 2) are excellent products.
At least they made D&D look fun, as opposed to last time. And what group of players would ever allow the DM to make all of the die rolls?
ReplyDeleteJeff: "Abed, you're not helping."
Abed: "What kind of Dungeon Master would I be if I helped?"
On topic, what about a modified sandbox where all of the characters were part of society that had a general goal, so that players could come in and out? Example: How about a rebellion and the characters are all part of it, picking up on possible missions based on whomever is available to do them?
We had a game going once that we decided we wanted to run as a sandbox. The shared world knowledge was identified as an issue so we all collaborated and used the Microscope rules to create our own campaign setting. Worked pretty well as a frame for the blank canvas our characters played on.
ReplyDelete