(this was originally - in part - responses of mine to a thread on G+)
I run my games via G+ Hangouts / TableTop Forge - my rolls are in the open, except for secret door checks / wandering monsters and the like.
The world is not always a fair place, and without risk the game (it is primarily a game, not a storytelling experience, although the story should evolve naturally through play) is bland.
How can there be excitement for overcoming great odds when fate and chance has no place in the equation?
I'm willing to improvise and let my players think up solutions / actions / flaming mine carts into orcs and the like that are not strictly covered by the rules - heck, I encourage it. That's the extent of my DM Fiat - letting the players find methods to increase their chances of success.
If the game uses dice, the dice are there for a reason. Denying them the ability to impact the course of the game removes much of "the game" from the experience.
I trust my players to play through the dice rolls, good or bad.
I am expected to do the same.
My players don't want fudged dice rolls, in their favor or against them. Sometimes they fail when the odds are heavily in their favor. Sometimes they unexpectedly succeed. Same with their adversaries.
For my group, that is part of the fun. Well, that and beer and derailing the game with outside the game talk. But that's how we roll - with honest rolls.
By fudging the rolls, you are moving from RPG to Storytelling. There is a huge gray area where they overlap, and fudging of dice is a part of that IMO.
That to me is the issue - are you playing a game or a looking for a storytelling experience?
My fear is that fudging dice rolls for "the story" takes importance away from "the characters". My feeling has always been that "the characters" should always come before whatever story I may have in mind, and that won't be the case if I fudge dice rolls.
Besides, I expect my players to be honest with their rolls. The least I can do is the same ;)
The Terrible Salt - For a generation, the tides at Vincha stopped completely. What was once an enormous tidal flat was lost under bitter waters. Now they have returned, and ...
2 hours ago
I get what you mean, but I'm not comfortable with saying "you are moving from RPG to Storytelling." I don't know if you are grouping these together, but there are storytelling games, and a lot of those games -- not all -- actually have strict rules in place with little room for fudging -- at least where the rules are concerned. What makes fudging dice for me unpalatable is that it removes agency from everyone and everything to accommodate one person's view of what should happen.ReplyDelete
@Joel - I get where you're coming from. When I refer to "storytelling games", the ones i'm referring to are rpgs where the GM puts his story over the actual game play - there's a predestination - he's telling his story. Thus, storytelling over gameplayReplyDelete
I know there is a large swath of storytelling games, many of which have built ways to "fudge" within the rules - in general, not my style of play but a legitimate game mechanic