Thursday, March 27, 2014

RPG Blog Carnival (March 2014): Virtual Table Tops and Online RPGs

I'm really not much for "blog carnivals" and the like. I enjoy reading them, mind you, it's the act of
participation that I often fail at. Probably has much to do with the fact that I usually have an abundance of crap to post about of my own and the distractions get lost in my own noise.

Not this time tho', and it's not just because this month's host is a member of the infamous "B Team". ;)

Nope, this time it's because it's a topic I hold near and dear - VTTs or Virtual Table Tops.

Let me give you a quick background of my VTT history. I've tried (and own licenses for where applicable) Klooge, Screenmonkey, MapTools, Battlegrounds RPG, iTableTop, Fantasy Grounds I and II, Roll20 and a small handful of others that escape me at the moment. Yes, a virtual plethora of virtual table tops.

As others, I really enjoyed playing with Fantasy Grounds II "as a player". Never got around to trying it as a GM because it was just too damn intimidating for me to even try to convert an adventure for use with the software, let alone a ruleset. Fantasy Grounds can do some amazing things in the hands of the right person - I just wasn't that person. Still, it is the interface that brought me back to the work of RPGs, and for that I am thankful.

Today, my poison of choice is Roll20. For a while, it was Tabletop Forge, but that was rolled into Roll20, and in the end it has worked out fine. In the beginning, however, it was a damn near bloody mess, as it didn't (does now, and does with ease) allow one to draw freehand - so if you wanted to actually map out the dungeon as your group progressed, you were shit outa luck.

Roll20 is truly night and day from where it was then to where it is now. These days, I mostly use maps from whatever adventure I'm running, drop it onto the virtual table top, cover it with "fog of war" and reveal the map as the party progresses. Heck, I don't even use tokens. I'm like "old school" "new tools".

So yeah, that's me pimping some VTTs for the current RPG Blog Carnival. VTTs allow me to game with folks from across the world with a schedule that works for all. As an adult with a family of my own and real employment, it sure as hell beats trying to organize a regular group in "meat space".


  1. I've used roll20, but I have a love/hate relationship. It can be easy to drop in and play, but I had players who were frustrated by it, even the little things like the dice rolling under windows rather than staying on top. But I agree: It's a lot better than it was after the Tabletop Forge merge.

    I've been debating FFG 2 for more than 2 years, so I broke down and bought it. And it works great . . .if the ruleset is great. I wanted to play Dragon Age with it, but the CoreRPG ruleset has too many issues that it really wasn't much of an advantage over Roll20. (They are improving that ruleset, however.) Then, after buying the C&C ruleset, I bought an adventure from FFG and was *really* disappointed at how poorly it was set up for FFG. No encounters. No items. Only a handful of enemies. I worked on the adventure, spending well over a day on it, and now I know the software better. So, there's a silver lining.

    So far,they seem good at different things. For supported games, FFG is very cool, and I think if I had to convert an adventure completely, I could probably do it a lot faster now. But for a rules light game or an unsupported system, it's easier to use Roll20.

  2. I've been running a game on Google+ hangouts for a while now, and every once in a while I get the itch to take another look at Roll20. I love the idea of dropping in a map and revealing it in the course of exploration, but I get hung up on the whole secret doors thing. Almost every dungeon has them, and it seems like there is no way to keep them secret short of completely redrawing the maps, which just seems like a little more work than I want to add to my prep sessions.


Tenkar's Tavern is supported by various affiliate programs, including Amazon, RPGNow,
and Humble Bundle as well as Patreon. Your patronage is appreciated and helps keep the
lights on and the taps flowing. Your Humble Bartender, Tenkar

Blogs of Inspiration & Erudition