(see http://timbrannan.blogspot.com/2011/10/more-osric-players-guide-woes.html for details)
Why is WotC suddenly getting defensive about the OSR? There are hints that D&D 5E, when it comes about, is going to be more "old school" in feel, if not execution, but is that a reason to issue a Cease and Desist on artwork that has been making the rounds of the OSR for years? Better question is does this Cease & Desist apply to those that have used the art in question over the past years, or just the latest OSRIC Player's Guide? If the offending art is removed from the book, is the book now in compliance?
Yes, I'm full of questions today. I'm just trying to figure out why artwork that has been in use for years is now in violation of WotC's IP. I need to look at the offending artwork and see if it replicates any WotC / TSR artwork. I sincerely doubt it does, but I'm not a lawyer (and I thank the Lord for that - I coulda been ;)
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Tenkar's Tavern is supported by various affiliate programs, including Amazon, RPGNow,
and Humble Bundle as well as Patreon. Your patronage is appreciated and helps keep the
lights on and the taps flowing. Your Humble Bartender, Tenkar
Blogs of Inspiration & Erudition
-
-
Deeper & Deeper Into The Station From Hell - The Red Room's Orbital Decay & Night Owl Workshop's Colonial Troopers - Session Report - Tonight's DM Paul's Colonial Troopers/Orbital Decay campaign and tonight's game picks right up where we were in last week's session. Our scientist Pu ar ...4 hours ago
-
More thoughts on Only Heroes Get to Resist - I've never implemented this rule, but I keep thinking about running a game that would use it: One Heroes Get to Resist I have a few more thoughts on it, n...5 hours ago
-
QuarHammer - I stumbled, addled, into my local semi-rural game store in search of off-brand Contrast paint to finish up Ionus Cryptborn, and while wandering around, I ...14 hours ago
-
More (Mostly Pointless) Messing About - I thought I would try an experiment: I re-scaled one of Bergman's 1:100 Char B-I (bis) models to 1:200 and printed it on my Mars Pro. It's the yellow ...14 hours ago
-
-
grodog's Founders & Legends and GaryCon XVI Convention Reports - 14-25 March 2024 - Part 3 - GaryCon XVI – Thank YOUs and SwagContinued from *Part 1 – Arrival through Founders & Legends and Interregnum Tuesday* and from *Part 2 - GaryCon XVI – 20-2...16 hours ago
-
#AtoZChallenge2024: V is for Vampire - [image: Dracula by Edgar Alfred Holloway] Dracula by Edgar Alfred HollowayLong before I was ever known as the "witch guy" I was the "vampire guy." A lot of...17 hours ago
-
Stonehell: Dipping their toes in the sewer - Session 227 was played on 9/24/23 Morgana, Magic User (Rob) Blotto, Goblin Fighter (Lanse) Koltic, Cleric 7 (NPC) Aroon, Fighter 5 (NPC) Jameth, Fighter 5...18 hours ago
-
AD&D ability tests, streamlined - As I've mentioned in my Hyperborea review (check it pout!), I really liked how the game tries to streamline AD&D ability checks: This is a simpler versi...18 hours ago
-
Gammarauders (1987) - From the web: Each player plays a large cybernetic creature known as a bioborg, which wanders about a radioactive science fiction landscape. Bioborgs are...19 hours ago
-
On preparing adventures for the Ghostbusters RPG - With my mind on a lot of things lately related to West End Games' classic RPG *Ghostbusters*, I was thinking of putting together a blog entry offering so...1 day ago
-
d100 Wasteland Weirdos - Possibly some Charginspire leaked onto our new album. Sampler short https://youtube.com/shorts/Yj7jn40iomM?si=dflfJ10EdYYJqMYr My Gunderholfen solo play...1 day ago
-
Standoff at Sandfell Sea Fort - By MalrexThe Merciless MerchantsOSR/1e/2eLevels 4-7 Eerie lights? Strange noises? Ships are sailing blind into the rough shores of the Bay of Saurvorn. Why...1 day ago
-
A World in a Magazine - Four years ago, I wrote about my history with miniature games and getting back into them during the lockdown. Summer 1995 saw me seduced by the world of ...1 day ago
-
Miskatonic Monday #278: The Viscount Who Left Me - Between October 2003 and October 2013, Chaosium, Inc. published a series of books for *Call of Cthulhu* under the Miskatonic University Library Associati...3 days ago
-
Living Rooms, Beyond the Living Room, and The Open Form Broadside - Living rooms set to liven up your RPG adventures, and a broadside journal set to stimulate those little grey cells... Rob Kuntz's latest releases! *Livin...3 days ago
-
Return to the Known Lands – Session #43 – Beware of Strangers with Magic Swords, Pt. 2 - PCs: - Frakus (Dw FM 3) - Osan (Elf F/MU 4/2) - Omes (Half FM) - Arro (MU 3) NPCs: - Marnes (CL 4) - Burdar (Dw FM 1) -...4 days ago
-
New Printable Scenery Campaign: Ramshackle & Ruin - [image: New Printable Scenery Campaign: Ramshackle & Ruin] I don't know how many of my peeps here are into 3d printing, but I'm always collecting the STL ...1 week ago
-
Play as Sculpture, Play as Prism - Watching my eldest child and friends engaging in imaginative play, I'm often struck by the fact that what seems to excite them is deciding who gets to be...1 week ago
-
OSR: Mirrors, Cubes, Rods, Staves, and the Deck of Motley Things - I've written another 10 pages of the Treasure Overhaul (title pending), a condensed magic item compendium for old-school games. Unlike the first two prev...1 week ago
-
Session #12 & Adventure Sites Compilation - Firstly, I wanted to let everybody know that Adventure Sites I by Coldlight Press is now available as a free download on DriveThruRPG. It includes my own...1 week ago
-
The Evolution of Gaming, or Why My Thoughts on Gaming have Changed Drastically Over Time - I have been thinking about this for quite a long time and though I am not an eloquent man, I thought I should put these random and chaotic thoughts down in...1 week ago
-
The Release of How to Make a Fantasy Sandbox and the Isle of Pyade - The Release With the successful conclusion and fulfillment of my Kickstarter, I am releasing How to Make a Fantasy Sandbox and The Isle of Pyade to the publ...2 weeks ago
-
Clerics of the Flanaess, Part 2 - Sorry it took so long to get to the next article in this series, but here we are! This continues the details of specialty clerics for the World of Greyhawk...2 weeks ago
-
On the Sector Turn - It's very simple. There are many important things cybertechtronically enhanced secret agents need to do: Buy illegal tanks with railguns. "Convince" the...2 weeks ago
-
Arsenic & Old Lace (a Review)... - The free-kriegsspiel revolution (or FKR; sometimes free-kriegsspiel roleplay) has been getting a lot of attention lately, which seems inevitable given re...3 weeks ago
-
The Light Dawns - THIS!!! Yes, a thousand times, this! Back in the day, I referred to this as “neo-classicalgaming,” which is to say, the sorts of games that came ou...3 weeks ago
-
Improvised Awful Lights Missions - Asking about The Awful Lights, a commenter asks: *I'd love to hear about how this is run - with the Handler determining mission location and objectives ...3 weeks ago
-
Jim Ward's Adventure in Gygax's Wonderland - Last weekend at GaryCon, many of us raised a glass to the memory of Jim Ward, who passed away just days before the convention. Ward was very helpful to m...3 weeks ago
-
It’s Tolkien Reading Day - I recently started rereading *The Silmarillion*. I had last read it over two decades ago. I liked it then but I’m really enjoying it this time! Despite b...4 weeks ago
-
Osr anchorites? - It's been a long time since I listened to any osr podcasts. Anchor was a lot of fun. I'm not sure if the community is still going? I deleted the app ...5 weeks ago
-
Chaos War Dogs - Welcome back to the Vault! My gaming partner and I had a fun day at the Meme Team doubles last weekend, placing mid-table results wise. My eye is now lo...5 weeks ago
-
ShadowDark Magic Items - The next campaign I run will use the ShadowDark RPG. I'm not sure when that'll be (I'm hoping a little later this year), but ShadowDark is my choice. I'v...1 month ago
-
Xandering, Jaquaysing, or Arneson-ing the Dungeon? - Yet another gamer firestorm arose shortly after the passing of Janelle Jaquays when it was noted that Justin Alexander had changed a rather well known p...2 months ago
-
GLOG Class: Bioweapon - I got this idea from mad gods on bear blog. Crab Evo from Kagaku Sentai Dynaman A thousand soldiers were slain. Too many to be tragic--this is just a fact...2 months ago
-
The Economy Engine, v0.2 - I made a thing. For D&D 3rd edition, so it might not be that interesting to a lot of people. But I made it and I think it’s cool. The 3rd edition Dungeon M...2 months ago
-
*'s in SpaaaaaAaaaace - A lot of SF (including a certain 2D6 RPG grandaddy) deal with ancient aliens taking humans from Earth and dropping them, fleas and all, on one or more w...2 months ago
-
[MODULE] The Webs of Past and Present & Cloister of the Frog-God (NOW AVAILABLE!) - Can you have enough frog-themed modules? I am pleased to announce the publication of two adventure modules, *The Webs of Past and Present *and *Cloister of...2 months ago
-
What Else Have I Got in Me? - Brechewold's been done for a little while. Still incredibly pumped to have this labor of love out in the company of LotFP's marvelously creative body of ...3 months ago
-
Housekeeping 2024 - Coactus Illustration © Heather Gwinn. A gift she gave me in 2013 for an edition of Miscreated Creatures which I hope exists someday. Coloring by me. I am a...3 months ago
-
Last move - to self-hosting! - As my vote regarding Substack in the “marketplace of ideas”, I’m moving to self-hosting. I’m now at (and hopefully staying for a long time at) Blog: ht...3 months ago
-
Sex-Crazed Falling Stars, Free Weather Magic, and Adventures: News of the Hill Cantons - *Grandma Gaya, the Rav-Witch of High Kezmarok*, seeks the stout of limb and humble of mind in the *obtaining of fallen stars* from an upcoming prophesied ...3 months ago
-
Time Rolls On - Today is December 31, 2023, in the mid-afternoon. In less than ten hours it will be 2024. 2023 2023 was a good year. But all years are good years. Both goo...3 months ago
-
Play Report: Skull Mountain - At the end of the last Skull Mountain session the PCs had retreated to safety at Owen's redoubt, met with visiting elves, and recovered from injuries ...5 months ago
-
-
Moving On... - So, my D&D 5e experiment has blown up the lab in a puff of green smoke leaving my face blackened like Wile E. Coyote after a failed roadrunner Acme trap...10 months ago
-
How to Keep Megadungeons Fresh - People often consider megadungeons boring. Not because the play style is boring, but because they are in the same locale for a majority of the campaign. If...11 months ago
-
ODIOUS UPLANDS and COMPLETELY UNFATHOMABLE DCC AT LAST - NOW AVAILABLE in PDF and Print on Demand:ODIOUS UPLANDS and COMPLETELY UNFATHOMABLE (DCC)CLICK HERE TO BUY NOW! SO YOU SURVIVED OPERATION UNFATHOMABLE? Od...1 year ago
-
The Blade Itself - I just finished listening to the audiobook of The Blade Itself, volume one in Joe Abercrombie’s The First Law trilogy. This was my first exposure to his wo...1 year ago
-
Master Treasure Seeker: A Dungeon23 MegaDungeon - Introduction - Sean McCoy, author of Mothership, posted an article on his substack titled Dungeon23 and it's taken the indie RPG scene by storm. So, I'm throwing my hat...1 year ago
-
Genteel Magistrate at FenCon XVIII - Victorious author Mike Stewart will be a guest at FenCon XVIII this weekend at the Sheraton DFW Airport hotel, 4440 W. John Carpenter Freeway, Irving, TX, ...1 year ago
-
Osamu Tezuka (1928 - 1989) - [image: Osamu Tezuka - Shonen Magazine Cover, 1970]Shonen Magazine Cover, 1970 [image: Osamu Tezuka - Shonen Magazine Cover Illustration 1970]Shonen Maga...1 year ago
-
Helvéczia: Journal de Campagne, 3 - We resumed play this past week, joining the company still within the farmstead where those that remain of the seven knaves are restrained or incapacitate...1 year ago
-
This is an Important Game Mechanic - *"That's the GM's Regional Map from my AOWG. And it's a damned good regional map. It's not a good map for a Simple Homebrew Campaign. It does some s$&...1 year ago
-
Clean Your Room - Looking back at my little blog here. That last post… wow, I was having fun playing WOW Classic! That was August of 1999 and I was having a blast… it was ...2 years ago
-
-
My RPG Zine Trilogy is on Kickstarter! - I can't believe I didn't post about it here! The Dead are Coming, Screams Amongst the Stars and Running Out of Time are on *Kickstarter right now!* Thes...3 years ago
-
Maximum HP 004, one week to go - Just one week to go for Maximum HP issue #004, the undead. We are pushing through stretch goals and wracking up contributions for the best issue yet. We...3 years ago
-
Steve Jackson Interview - James Maliszewski recently did an interview with Steve Jackson over on his Grognardia blog. Steve chats about the beginnings of The Fantasy Trip and upcomi...3 years ago
-
The Hero’s Journey 2nd Edition, Campbellian roleplaying at its best! - (this review done using the reviewers own purchased copy) I have been a James Michael Spahn fan since he wrote his Swords & Wizardry Companion. His writing...3 years ago
-
Undermountain Map Origins - As documented on the Ruins of Undermountain sales page, "TSR didn't actually use Ed Greenwood's original maps," at least not in their entirety. This post d...3 years ago
-
WB:FMAG Total Print Sales - Hello Folks, The last time I did a quick sales report was in September 2018. I pulled reports from Amazon, Lulu and DrivethruRPG from October to current fo...4 years ago
-
The Minotaur for Old-School Essentials - *Minotaur* *Requirements:* Minimum STR 9, Minimum CON 9 *Prime Requisite:* STR and CON *Hit Dice:* 1d10 *Maximum Level:* 8 *Armor:* Leather, including shield...4 years ago
-
WIZARDS OF POHJOLA - Init +0 Melee Atk • sword or dagger +1 (1d5 or 1d3) Ranged Atk • hot iron sparks +3 (1d4+2 to two targets within 20' but not closer than 5') AC 14 HD 12d...4 years ago
-
The Withered Crag custom print version for sale again - Just re-enabled the direct sales button for the custom print (classic style detached cover) version of F4 The Withered Crag, and also for F3 Many Gates of...4 years ago
-
Dungeons & Dragonmead Fall Schedule - *As you know, I run public classic Dungeons & Dragons games at **The Loaded Die**/Metro Detroit Game Night's Board Game Nigh at **Dragonmead**, in Warren...4 years ago
-
-
D&D Sling Damage vs. Large Targets - In many early editions of D&D, weapons were assigned two damage values: one for small/medium targets (i.e. man-sized) and one for large targets (giants and...4 years ago
-
James A. Smith, Jr. Memorial Video - A beloved father, devoted friend, and D&D Dungeon Master extraordinaire. We miss you! To view video, click here Memorial Video Note - The original video...5 years ago
-
Let's Talk About Pacing! - The idea, I think, is that the RPG is ultimately about the long game. Even rolling back to the early days of Basic & Expert, the goal of the player was...5 years ago
-
Profane and Profound Prep Part 2 - This is part 2 of my work to edit my magic items for a DMsGuild release, along with adding cursed items along the way. Here is part 1. Bone of a Saint 8000...5 years ago
-
SHORT BREAK. - I'm going to take a break for a week or so and will start up again in the New Year. Thanks for reading and we'll start with Level 6 when I get back.5 years ago
-
Iain Lovecraft, 3D Sculptor - Nope, it's got nothing to do with Cthulhu. I just did a video conversation with Iain Lovecraft, who designs 3D miniatures and terrain. If you're not doi...5 years ago
-
New website! - Slowly but surely, all the content here will make its way — in updated form! — to my new website: timbannock.com. For fairly obvious reasons, that site wil...5 years ago
-
Please Update Your Link! - If you're seeing this, it means your link to the Greyhawk Grognard blog is out of date. Please update your link to www.greyhawkgrognard.com (RSS feed is h...5 years ago
-
Mord Mar - Session 6 - We weren't able to play Mord Mar last week, due to a family funeral. This week we played on Monday for the first time, due to kids returning to school and ...5 years ago
-
A Small, Quiet Plea - There has been a great deal of discussing political agendas, social grievances, and personal attacks within the little corner of gaming that is my hobby....5 years ago
-
Don’t Sleep It’s Broken - Expanding/editing my comments from What Makes Something Broken G+ thread: “Broken”, for me, is anything that makes normal character choices, tactics, or ro...6 years ago
-
Swords & Wizardry Light-Themed Birthday Party - Last month, my wife and I helped our oldest to celebrate his birthday in style. Ever since 2013, we have hosted a themed birthday party for our now-15-ye...6 years ago
Can anyone confirm that it was artwork based on this rubber monster which was used as a D&D monster that's included in the OGL / d20 SRD is the source of the C&D?
ReplyDeleteThat seems really unlikely - but I'm late tuning in so maybe I missed details in some of those deleted blog/forum posts.
It is really odd that years old pieces of art in an OSRIC work are suddenly an issue for WotC.
ReplyDeleteI really didn't think WotC paid attention to Old School publications...
Is it certain this isn't some kind of sick prank?
ReplyDeleteWas it an issue of the artwork being more or less traced / copied too closely rather than the actual subject of the artwork?
ReplyDeleteI'm beginning to think the issue here is OSRIC is not published under the OGL (if I recall correctly) therefore it doesnt have the protections afforded by the OGL.
ReplyDeleteYou can't copyright game rules, but you can copyright art. So that might be the angle used here.
and i think i recall incorrectly... ah well... another fine idea proven wrong ;)
ReplyDeleteAs I understand it, the offending images are original pieces, but they depict protected content; one of them's a picture of a beholder, I believe.
ReplyDeleteIt all seems a bit fishy to me as it's original work, regardless of the subject, but I'm no expert.
The artists public statements (now deleted) are as kelvin reported, above. The Beholder and Rust Monster appeared in some stock art, which had been on the market at RPGNOW for years. I don't know if the art appeared in the Player's Book. According to Steve, the C&D was directed at the stock art pack, but he pulled everything down, with an eye towards assessing the entire situation.
ReplyDeleteI strongly suspect, this was WotC doing a little saber rattling, just so no one gets too casual about their IP.
ReplyDeleteWith so much OGL activity going on, I see where they might decide to draw a hard line in the dirt.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete@Bree Yark!: Can you let us know if this is an issue relating to just a drawing of a single monster or if this involves a claim against more than one item?
ReplyDelete@Bree Yark: The whole thing is just... strange. Going after an art product that's been up for a few years is really weird.
ReplyDeleteI'm curious about a C&D via e-mail. I would ask that the sender submit the letter via traditional methods, that of registered mail. Upon its receipt, I would call the office and make an appointment to speak to the attorney who drafted it. There's nothing wrong in asking for clarification.
ReplyDeleteI say this because headers in e-mails aren't impossible to forge and it couldn't hurt to make sure this is a legitimate grievance.
Smells fishy to me....
ReplyDeleteGood Publicity though :)
>>I really didn't think WotC paid attention to Old School publications...
ReplyDeleteThey do, and have since OSRIC was first released.
@sean willis - Good Publicity for who? Bree who had to pull his product line from OBS and closed his blog?
ReplyDeleteOr for WotC? 99% of their consumers have little to no idea the OSR / Old School Gaming even exists.
Somehow I expect that this is only the first C&D request this corner of the hobby is going to see in the near future. I hope I'm wrong...
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteIt's possible they may get a bit more vigilant about things, but I really don't see some great era of persecution, heading the OSR's way. :)
ReplyDeleteAs for 5e, blog post on why I don't think it's really going to matter, coming soon.
Because I can spread around my bs opinions, with the best of 'em. :)
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete@bree yark! My thoughts (not yours) is that the someone who put out two products in recent weeks that infringed on copyrighted art (previously published by TSR/WotC) and material that wasn't released under the OGL, but then used the OGL in their work, might have wakened the sleeping giant. Or maybe it's just that time in the cycle of things for it to remind this corner of the hobby who's boss.
ReplyDelete@James - If you have a blog, you're in the media, making you "an expert" on the subject matter. I look forward to your thoughts :)
My thoughts are conjecture. If I had other evidence then circumstantial and the voices in my head, believe me, I'd show it ;)
Also, I think OSRIC in particular has been a sore spot for WotC. I don't believe Stuart Marshal and the powers that be ever negotiated the issues succesfully, with WotC having the stand the it felt OSRIC went beyond the bounds of the OGL, but they never persued it.
ReplyDeleteI remember reading where Stuart wrote that a WotC employee contacted him and Stuart then informed said employee that OSRIC was an OGL release and to have WotC Lawyers contact his legal representative if there were any further questions. :)
ReplyDeleteFrom what I gathered, that was pretty much the extent of it. I know of no official statement from WotC, regarding OSRIC.
So is this an OGL issue, or a regular copyright issue? Was the Art Pack published with the OGL license and/or did it include names for the monsters in the illustrations or was it just some drawings?
ReplyDelete@James - I believe Ryan Dancy alluded to it on ENWorld a few years back. The issues were experiences tables and the combat matrix / chart.
ReplyDeleteBree Yark! has stated in one of his deleted comments that the C&D was via email. He also said:
ReplyDelete"I recently received a C&D order from WotC. According to the C&D order, they claim two of my drawings from one of my stock art packs violated their copyrights to the rust monster and the beholder.
It has nothing to do with the OGL/SRD (my stock art didn't use or refer to it), it was not about trademarks or names (there were no names used). There weren't any stats or descriptive text given. Just the images.
Also keep in mind, these were drawings I did myself, and they were original (they were not copies of a specific picture).
Furthermore, the stock art was put up for sale YEARS ago. According to the C&D order, they had just become aware of it.
"
As he said, the two images appeared without description or name and they appeared in the character creation and spells sections respectively. Being a player's guide there is no monster section.
His "rust monster" image is pretty well identical to the rubber monster on the right in the link from Stuart (first comment above). Given that the monster pre-dates anything by Gygax and given that Bree Yark! didn't in any way identify it as a rust monster, I can't see that WotC has a leg to stand on.
As for OSRIC, Stuart Marshall stated:
"WOTC did issue me with an email asking me to cease distribution of OSRIC when it first came out. I said no."
Bree Yark! likewise received an email. Perhaps he should've simply said no too. I'm beginning to think he gave up too easily. Does a C&D have to be in writing to be legal? Does an email suffice? Could the email be a prank by someone who wanted to stir things up for fun? It's certainly easy enough to fake such a thing, conmen do it with fake bank and ebay emails all the time. I'm with Christian, I'd be making inquiries before doing anything about such an email.
@ Tenkar - You're going to send me googling, now! :)
ReplyDelete@james - hopefully your google-fu and my memory meet somewhere close ;)
ReplyDeleteI think the comments were from 2007
Oh, my google-fu rocks. Here's Mr. Dancy on Enworld.
ReplyDelete"I have problems with OSRIC. I believe that some of the content in OSRIC is copyrightable, and that it has not been shared by WotC via the OGL. Specifically, I will mention the class charts & the to-hit charts. These charts are copyrightable; they are not simple expressions of a mathematical formula, but contain specific human-selected values in certain areas. The courts have repeatedly found that such tables are protected by copyright.
"I think that it is very difficult to "recreate" a pre-existing RPG system without crossing that "invisible iine" between copyright and not-copyrightable. I'm not saying it can't be done, but the more "quirks" that system has - the more it relies on non-intuitive game systems, and less on simple math, the harder it will be to safely clone. I think it would be nice, but not likely, for WotC to add OSRIC to the SRD, which would clearly put it under the OGL, and clear up any potential confusion about the matter."
yep, that's the dancy quote i was thinking about
ReplyDeleteMr Dancy doesn't have the faintest clue what he's talking about.
ReplyDeleteI mean, he knows the OGL. It's just that he hasn't compared the OSRIC class charts and "to hit" charts with the AD&D ones.
The Cleric to hit charts are identical in all but formatting. Ditto for the Thief to hit charts.
ReplyDeleteThe Fighter charts use the alternate scheme mentioned in the DMG, where the Fighter improves by one every level instead of by 2 every other level.
The MU charts differ, with OSRIC's MU having a poorer chance to hit at higher levels.
Monster To Hit values differ. OSRIC's monsters are a tad tougher! :)
Believe it or not, the formatting's the important bit!
ReplyDeleteGame rules cannot be copyrighted. Simple algorithmic progressions cannot be copyrighted. But there's precedent to suggest that a table format can be copyrighted even if the data within it is not. This is a case where OSRIC avoids breach of copyright by presenting the data in a different way.
And that's the whole nature of OSRIC. The underlying game rules and algorithmic progressions are not copyright, but the presentation and format, the exact choice of words, the layout of the tables, etc. is copyrightable and copyrighted. Thus to avoid breach of copyright, all I need do is change the presentation.
I certainly wasn't attempting to support Mr. Dancey's argument. Merely bringing forth what facts I could, since I can't bring forth very much regarding the nitty-gritty of the law, here.
ReplyDeleteAs always, whatever support I have to offer goes to OSRIC and The First Edition Society.
I smell more of Steve needing to be at the forefront of the OSR than anything from WotC. Absofuckinglutely funny how everything is hidden and secret with this mysterious C&D.
ReplyDeleteWow...the very thing I was talking about the other day and the very thing I have been preaching about for some time.
ReplyDeleteThere are so many violations currently circulating, both free and commercial, that they can have a field day. Part of Dancey's bit refers to the level titles being used in the charts that I mentioned the other day as well.
Yes, they read our blogs, yes they don't like the fact that we exist and would love to find a way to get rid of us.
Just remember, the company currently kicking their ass in sales uses the same license and material and they wouldn't mind taking out two birds with one stone.
Also keep in mind, these were drawings I did myself, and they were original (they were not copies of a specific picture).
ReplyDeleteAnd this is the key thing to me. I'm nowhere near an expert, but I'm not sure they've got a case here if it's original work, regardless of the subject.
If it was a Beholder and a Rust Monster it's not exactly like those are original creations in the first place...
ReplyDeleteStuart we've had this conversation before and I hate that it has put us on opposite sides of the fence since we agree on more than we disagree on (yes, I read your posts :).
ReplyDeleteI don't know how Canadian law is but under U.S. law if you DON'T defend your IP you can lose it. The courts force companies into action.
As for what they call IP the Yuan-Ti is not original at all but an ancient mythological creature and yet they insist on it being their IP.
We will see more of this. They are in deep trouble and they will be going after this again and again because they have deep pockets.
There is only one rule that counts in the U.S.- if the little guy finds himself standing in a court of law, even if he is right, he has already lost.
@ADD Grognard née AD&D Grognard:
ReplyDeleteYou are confusing Copyright and Trademark law. Trademarks that are not enforced can become genericized so companies need to defend their trademarks to prevent this from happening.
Copyrights do not need to be enforced to prevent them entering the public domain. Orphaned works are undefended but do not automatically enter the public domain. They are still copyrighted.
The words "Yuan Ti" are copyrighted (and possibly trademarked?) to TSR/WotC/Habsro. The concept of "Snake Man" is not. Similarly "Illithid" and "Mind Flayer" are product identity (aka Copyrighted) but "Squid Headed Psychic Cultist or Alien" is not.
There is only one rule that counts in the U.S.- if the little guy finds himself standing in a court of law, even if he is right, he has already lost.
This isn't true. There's also a risk to a company filing a groundless lawsuit that can't be underestimated, particularly in the age of social media.
This business of lawsuits being won on the depth of your wallet rather than the strength of your case is one of the reasons why I took editorial responsibility for OSRIC and Matt Finch did not. I'm British.
ReplyDeleteWell, so's Matt Finch, technically--he has dual nationality--but he lives in the states and has practised law there. I've never set foot in the US, and I do not submit to US law or US rules of procedure. And the OGL doesn't specify choice of law.
This is something that many people who've given a less than fully informed opinion about OSRIC, including lawyers such as the esteemed Mr Kenzer, have failed to grok. If anyone wanted to take action against me they would have to do so under the law of England and Wales, under which, the loser pays the winner's legal costs. Thus I could engage lawyers to defend me on a "no win, no fee" basis. (Before publishing OSRIC, I spoke to a law firm and made sure they would accept instructions of this kind.)
Of course, in 2011, we know much more about what WOTC will overlook, from the OSR, and what they will attempt to shut down. But back then we were planning for a worst case scenario.
We were confident that OSRIC was perfectly lawful, but we weren't confident that WOTC would accept that. Now we are.
@Stuart Marshal - that is an extemely insightful post in the developement of OSRIC. Well played!
ReplyDeleteGood, I'm glad you thought so. :) I'm trying to be open in the hope of reducing the amount of speculation.
ReplyDeleteYou see, periodically, there are bouts of internet speculation about legal issues involving the OSR. These never seem to involve Labyrinth Lord, or S&W, but I've noticed that OSRIC is always mentioned!
Once you connect the word "OSRIC" with words like "compliance" and "infringement" and "cease and desist", what you're doing is, you're damaging my business. OSRIC's advertised in one place: online. I have to be mindful of what people see when they search.
Don't get me wrong. I understand why people are interested, and I know why there's a resurgence of interest now. What I do ask is that later on, you try to balance this discussion with a subsequent discussion that isn't about copyright issues or legality, please!
Thanks very much
Stuart we have been over this ground and you still do not grasp U.S. copyright law (which is where I live and have to abide by said laws).
ReplyDeleteYou can not 'copyright' a word. You can trademark it.
This art situation seems to fall in that gray area of dilution, where if a product appears to be something it is not and a customer might mistake it for another companies product they ask that it be removed.
The Yuan-Ti situation is a matter of license, not copyright or trademark. This is the place where people misinterpret the OGL most often.
When you use the OGL, and by that I mean any IP contained in the SRD, you are agreeing to do things and waive certain rights that would otherwise fall under copyright law.
You can't pick and choose which parts of the SRD and the OGL you want to comply with. It is the most straight forward license I have ever seen and there is no 'wiggle room'. Because you say something is 'groundless' that doesn't mean a judge will agree with you when he or she is presented with the OGL and sees that it is a valid license that has been in use for a decade.
There is no law that says you have to agree to the OGL. But if you use the SRD material you are agreeing to abide by the terms of that license and it would take precedent over standard copyright because you have waived protection under copyright law.
@Stuart M.- Hey, you guys got on the map because you were the first to do this and survive basically unchallenged. A little controversy every now and again is good for business. Doesn't affect my opinion of you and your product at all. ;)
Keep up the good work!
@Stuart M - OSRIC was my introduction to the OSR (after C&C). I don't see this as a reflection on you, or OSRIC, but rather 3rd parties.
ReplyDeleteI do find WotC's response to be interesting, as much as the timing as anything else/
Stuart we have been over this ground and you still do not grasp U.S. copyright law (which is where I live and have to abide by said laws).
ReplyDeleteI understand U.S. copyright law and when I don't I have a team of lawyers who I can, and do, ask for clarification. This includes asking for clarification around these topics so that I know I'm not shooting from the hip.
Do you have any sort of professional background in this area or frequent access to legal counsel, or are you just an enthusiastic blogger? :)
You can not 'copyright' a word. You can trademark it.
That's true, but it's not quite what we're talking about. The Gaiman vs McFarlane case was about copyright and not trademark.
You can copyright character. I could publish a story about a Japanese Schoolgirl and name her "Yuan Ti". I could not publish a story about snake-men and name them Yuan Ti. Similarly I couldn't publish stories with Squid headed men named Illithid, Quarren or Ood. I could publish a story with squid headed men named Squidlar though.
There is no law that says you have to agree to the OGL. But if you use the SRD material you are agreeing to abide by the terms of that license and it would take precedent over standard copyright because you have waived protection under copyright law.
It feels like you are suggesting, as you have before, that if you were to publish something with material that was also included under the OGL/SRD you would be compelled to abide by the terms of the OGL/SRD and give up some of your rights. For example if you were to include "Goblin" or "Vorpal Sword" or had a "Shambling Mound" monster.
This is not the case at all. You can't trick people into agreeing to a business contract.
To be surrounded by lawyers and yet none seem to be able to read:
ReplyDeleteOGL 1.0a
3.Offer and Acceptance. By using the Open Game Content you indicate your acceptance of the terms of this license.
How is that a trick? That is as plain English a clause as you will ever find in a license.
And my ass rides on my words everyday. I publish (first alpha out and more material to follow) so I make damn certain I know what something means before I publish it.
As for repercussions:
From The OGL FAQ:
Q: What are the penalties for violating the terms of the License?
A: You are potentially liable to three groups of people, for various types of lawsuits.
First, you could be sued by anyone listed in the COPYRIGHT NOTICE section related to any Open Game Content you copied, modified or distributed. Second, you could be sued by anyone who receives Open Game Content from you and relies on you to ensure that your work conforms to the terms of the License who subsequently discovers problems with the Open Game Content they received from you. Third, you could be sued by someone with a copyright or trademark interest in the work you've distributed, even if you did so while relying on a previous publisher's representation that they had followed the terms of the License.
You could be sued for a copyright infringement, you could be sued for misuse of a trademark, you could be sued for breach of contract, and you could be sued for any number of torts related to those three actions.
If you have concerns about the scope of your liability under the Open Game License, you should consult with your legal counsel.
I think that's pretty clear there.
I'm not some 12 year old blogger, Stuart. My background is sales, marketing, stock market and mortgage firms. And it doesn't hurt that I can read.
As for the 'trick' part, you might want to check out how Microsoft is able to enforce a EULA by you just switching on the power to your new computer the first time. There is a way around it, but you have to know how to do it.
Your apples and oranges approach to the 'Yuan-Ti' reference is irrelevant. We are talking about gamers making games out of game material. Thus the license is enforceable. The Apple lawsuits proved that time and again.
To be surrounded by lawyers and yet none seem to be able to read
ReplyDeleteClearly this is the only possible explanation. :)
ADD Grognard:
ReplyDelete"3.Offer and Acceptance. By using the Open Game Content you indicate your acceptance of the terms of this license."
By posting on this blog thread you have all indicated your acceptance that you are slaves of mighty S'mon! Kneel before me, vassals!! :P
Or: no, Contract & IP law don't work like that. At all. *sheesh*
-S'mon, 8th level law lecturer.