There was a lot of chatter about the Destination Fantastic Kickstarter both while it was funding and immediately after it funded - right up against the clock when it did.
Simply put, this is one of the worst presentations of a Kickstarter I can recall coming across. Its got flash and one of the best video presentations I've ever seen, but the Kickstarter page itself is a horrid mess.
Let me state something right off the bat: although the perception by many was that this was a Kickstarter being run by Stefan Pokorny & Satine Phoenix, this wasn't the case. Sure, they are the stars of the show, but the KS was run by the producer of Dwarvenaut (a documentary about Stefan and available on Netflix - well worth the time to watch if you haven't already, it's entertaining). So, this is really a critique of a Kickstarter run by Ron Harbin.
The first issue, and it's a biggie, is that there is no real sense of what the average backer is getting of value for their cash.
Here's what you get for 10 bucks:
An astounding digital postcard of our Iceland adventures!Yep, pretty much a whole lotta nothing. 3 bucks gives you the same without the digital postcard.
Plus a heartfelt thank you + EXCLUSIVE INFO UPDATES, behind-the-scenes access, videos, and more!
What does 15 bucks give you?
The HD digital edition of Episode One of Destination Fantastic, the Iceland Excursion! Follow Stefan and Satine as they climb glaciers, explore dormant volcanoes, and turn the pages of the ancient Icelandic tomes that started it all!Notice it apparently lacks exclusive info updates and the rest of the goodies from the lower pledge levels. Well, probably not but shows a sloppy presentation of backer levels.
Destination Fantastic Episode 01
Destination Fantastic Digital Postcard
25 bucks gives you the full season, but the season only funded for 1 episode. Oh, and a Digital Storytellers Thesaurus by Troll Lord Games.
As for the rest of the backer levels, they are a mess. There are a total of 28 backer levels, which is probably 20 too many. Did I mention there was an "angel backer" right before the end of funding? It needed $100k to fund. It hit exactly $109,230. That "angel backer" jumped in for $9k right at the end. Who the fuck with $9k to drop on a KS waits until there is less than half an hour to go in the funding period?
How about that $100k funding goal? With about 48 hours left it needed about $25k. With lofty stretch goals in the millions of dollars, why did it perform so badly?
Well, aside from the poor and confusing presentation, there was the perception that backers were paying for a bunch of rich people to have fun and go on vacation, then film their fun for the non-rich people to watch.
Yep, that's a comment from an earlier post on this blog. While I don't fully agree with the perception, I certainly understand it.
Then there is the issue of funding the stretch goals themselves.
The first episode funded at $100k. So, that would seem to be your baseline breakeven cost. One assumes that also includes initial equipment purchases and the like. Also, its money already spent, as the first episode is already filmed. Ah-ha! Now you see why the project needed to fund (KS is fund or get nothing, but I digress.)
The never-ending, far too full of explanations that I felt like my pocket was being fleeced section on Risks & Challenges states: between fees, rewards, and shipping, about 35 cents of every dollar is gone before actual projects costs. I'll accept that number.
So, if the first episode funded with $100k, and that includes initial equipment cost, that later episodes would be cheaper to produce, but you would be wrong. As the stretch goals are structured, each stretch goal episode costs between $400k and $450k to produce.
Yes, you read that right.
Here, peek for yourself.
This project should never have funded. It should have rebooted with a clearer presentation and more reasonable stretch goals. So, although technically not a "failure to fund" it probably would have been better for all if that had been the case. As it stands now, I fully expect a Destination Fantastic Episode 2 Kickstarter in a few months. Hopefully, Ron Harbin takes the time to try a different approach when he takes his second bite at the apple.
edit: I should also note that I suspect there was a thought process that due to the huge success Stefan has had with his own Dwarven Forge Kickstarters, there would be a significant carry over to Destination Fantastic. Obviously, that is NOT the case. Somebody failed n their Marketing Skill Roll pretty badly.
"Well, aside from the poor and confusing presentation, there was the perception that backers were paying for a bunch of rich people to have fun and go on vacation, then film their fun for the non-rich people to watch." This is exactly what I was thinking when I saw the news of the KS. Granted I'm a little biased against Mr. Porkony when he drunkenly bid on my winning auction basically just to take an extra $100 out of my pocket. I hear he's a great guy, but every time I've run into him he's been drunk and stupid....and I've come across him several times now.ReplyDelete
What an idiotic Kickstarter. I think the only lesson to be learned is that there are a lot of people in the tabletop rpg community who are desperate to feel like they are a part of something *AND* have a lot of money to burn.ReplyDelete
Who are these rich gamers? You look at a forum like Dragonsfoot and you see a lot of "wish I had the money to go to that con" and "wish I had the money to contribute to the City State Kickstarter" and such.Delete
But yeah, gamers seem to want to belong, plus the cults of personality I thought were dying out seem to actually be growing strong. Satine talks to a guy for two minutes on a con floor and he suddenly thinks they're besties and throws his disability check money at a kickstarter. It's almost sad.
Tenker, thanks for pointing out the holes in this thing. There is still so much hucksterism in gaming. As they say light is the best disinfectant.
I think this is a product that no one needs and few people actually want. Didn't back.ReplyDelete
It would have funded quicker if they offered Satine's previous video productions.ReplyDelete
Yes, I've seen some of Satine's videos, so I know she can at least hold her end up (so to speak).Delete
The Forge guy actually produces things in the community, but I don't really get why Satine has any celebrity status. Gross-out low budget porn films, an association with the Freddy Kruger of gaming (Zak Smith), pay to play D&D games at a comic book store, and the very occasional appearance on Geek and Sundry to me does not a celebrity make. I'm so shocked people are shelling out money for these people to enjoy world travel. Its so idiotic.ReplyDelete
I guess I should be grateful though. In an alternate reality this could be starring RPG Pundit and Grognardia James.
Not a fan, or at least enough of a fan to send these folks on nerdy travels. This year at NTRPG I lost a lot of sleep due to a suite having a constant party, with the door to the room being left open late into the night.ReplyDelete
The last night they moved me to a quiet floor. Turns out it was the Dwarven forge party/gaming room. Guess I've officially achieved crotchety old man status now 😜
Thanks for using my quote! Ha.. Didn't think I'd actually make a blog post. I really didn't think they were going to make their funding.. Then out of nowhere, like you have stated here, BOOM! Funded. Crazy. I'm very curious who this mystery backer was.ReplyDelete
Was the mystery of the "angel backer" ever solved?ReplyDelete