I remember playing Champions back in the day when it was a boxed set that requires a shit ton of D6s to game with. Now it seems like you need a shit ton of books. Still, the price is right to take a peek, assuming the peek is worth taking.
Is the HERO System worth the taxing on my mind it will entail to learn a new system (I'm assuming what i played back in the day is barely recognizable compared to what I played in the mid 80s)?
Structurally about the same. The rules have become more organized and perhaps legalistic in some ways -- I've seen some bits that basically clarify how the rules are supposed to work where someone found a loophole -- but overall I think more consistent. Fundamentally much is the same, it's mostly the particulars that have changed.
Still, Energy Blast is 5 points per d6 and Killing Blast is three times as expensive, and you can still build your powers the way you want, if you can afford them.
I think I'd argue that the complete rules above are actually a pretty bad way to learn the game. They are encyclopedic in their thoroughness, and don't lend themselves nearly so well to a new player as one of the smaller options - the Basic Rulebook, Champions Complete (if you want strictly supers), Monster Hunters International (for play in the world of Larry Correia's MHI) or the forthcoming Fantasy Hero (currently in Kickstarter with a $10 PDF entry point, with a focus on fantasy games, naturally).
I concur. I didn't get into HERO until the Sixth Edition and I found trying to learn the game with the two massive Sixth Edition tomes, collectively 1200 pages in length to be too daunting. I ending up getting the Basic Rulebook to learn the game and then reference the giant blue books when needed. Ultimately, I found getting into HERO like learning a new language. It's an endeavor not to be entered lightly, requires an commitment and an investment of time but once you get it, it's like a whole new world is open to you that you were excluded from before. Not sure if that helps but for ten bucks you really don't have much to lose. The great artwork in the HERO core is at least worth ten bucks so you'll get your money's worth regardless. As for needing a shit ton of books, you don't need anything beyond the core but once you crack the code, you'll want to get more than the core, so much more. When you consider that fifth and sixth edition are more or less the same thing, there are dozens and dozens of gloriously crunchy books to get. I now have over 50!
The hero system is a beautifully balanced system. A work of art. Brutalist, modern art. Evocative and powerful and almost overwhelming in its perfectly balanced fury.
It is one game where the mechanics jump off the page and can you by the throat and throttle you into awed supplication.
As a game, it's very dense and slow. If you like 4e, then you will nut yourself over Hero.
In other words, it's the Grape Nuts of RPGs.
I have over a hundred superheroes and supervillains lovingly constructed down to the last character point. Perfect works of art that do exactly what I mean for them to do mechanically. I could pull them out and play with any Hero group anywhere in the universe and in any century, and they would behave perfectly, like so many clockwork gnomes animated by a divine clockmaker.
And so these tiny works of art, each painstakingly crafted over hours and sometimes days, sit in a binder in a box under a table in my basement.
Maybe forever.
The game's the thing, man. And the game is slow, and doesn't suit my style.
The rules are slow. They are laid out very well. But they are so dense, you have to really want it to get the most out of the system.
There's no soul there. The rules have no soul. Nothing animates them.
Even in play, the GM can use them to make whatever he wants to. This is more true than in almost any other game system.
But instead of a world, it's a puppet show. The pieces all move exactly right. But there's no soul to it.
I have an incredibly deep admiration for Hero. I really, really, really want to love it. But instead of love, it's this really platonic deep respect.
The Hero System, it's destined to always live in my friend-zone.
Hero System is fundamentally the same game it was in the 80s. With expanded options and details. The new Champions book is a standalone game in its own right so I would start with that. Then use the main hero system book as a reference.
Get Hero Basic or Champions Complete (not on sale, unfortunately), and wait for Fantasy Hero Complete. Based on your schedule Erik I think you'll find little time to absorb the monstrosity that is the Hero 6th main books! I know I can't. That said I'll still probably get them for the hell of it.
Don't bother with any of this stuff, this is reference material for the die hard completist who wants every 'i' dotted and 't' crossed for them, and who has next to no imagination. The *only* book you need to run Hero games is *Champions Complete*. Although it is written with a superhero experience in mind, it is totally usable to run sci-fi, fantasy, modern espionage, whatever floats your boat. I used Champions 1e back in the day for precisely the same - all it takes it a little old school imagination.
I ran a Champions game for my old school fantasy group last summer, only one of whom had any experience with it, and that was from 20 years previously. The others approached with massive trepidation and foreboding as they had all heard how difficult Hero was, how mathematically intense it was, how it was crunch to the point of despair, but within 20 minutes they were all engrossed and couldn't believe how it had acquired such a bad rep. Half of them went and bought their own copies of *Champions Complete* over the next few days. Seriously.
That two page "everything you need to know about Hero" document really does distil the rules down to two pages. There is a single unified mechanic that anyone can explain / understand in 5 mins, then you're off. Character generation can be as light or intense as you like. Even complicated characters can be rattle off in 5 minutes using the excellent Hero Designer character software. However, for your typical fantasy characters there is no more to it than buy your stats, buy your skills, maybe a couple of talents (eidetic memory, etc), get some disadvantages, and a spell or two if you're that way inclined.
Now, I'm not saying this is an easy jump if you're a class 'n' level kind of guy who likes to know exactly what you get and when, with no messing around. However, if you're more at the RuneQuest / d100 end of the old school spectrum, it really is no more than that with the random stats replaced by a point buy system.
A bad ref can make any game system suck and be onerous to the players. Hero is no exception to that, but it is better at making bad refs worse, no question about it.
In summary, it really isn't as much of a big deal of a system as it's made out to be. Although Hero Games did try to make it one with the disastrous 6th Edition and nearly went under (deservedly) as a result. I reckon the *Fantasy Hero Complete* Kickstarter PDF is likely worth $10 of anyone's money.
Hope that helps with the informed choice thing :-)
Just get a used copy of the 4th edition Big Blue Book. Every version since has been turned into law school textbook style and will make your eyes glaze over. So many Hero players believe in letter not spirit of the law, the writers feel they have to spell out every possible interpretation of any phrase, it's very "That depends on what 'is' is" in style.
I'm a lifetime (30+ yrs) Champions / HERO guy, but no fan of 6th Edition. In fact, I think it killed the line by being a flavorless, fix-what-isn't broken, overly-long monstrosity.
And after several false starts at teaching newbies the rules that went wonky (mostly slow combat, and rules munchkinery), I''ll never play with rookies again...which is no way to ensure the system grows and thrives.
Almost made a go of Fantasy Hero, but it was too much crunch for me to handle. Champions suffered from both complexity and imbalance, build your hero wrong and you are siting on you ass watching someone else finish the fight. Might pick up the .pdf anyway. At least as a .pdf it won't break my arm to pick it up.
Still in the dungeon
-
We played in Vic's Felltower adjacent game again today. summary tomorrow,
but we smashed a largish band of D&D style hobgoblins and took some loot,
but did...
Chucky Shorts
-
Chucky season 2 is finally availability in Peacock and season 3 premieres
soon. I’ve decided I would watch the whole franchise (which is available on
Peaco...
Fighting fantasy and gaming ramble.
-
It's time for a change of pace. I'm going to start working on a small
campaign using the original fighting fantasy rules as detailed in Fighting
Fantasy...
Lizards & Birds & Pirates, Oh My!
-
The Ages of Man have long since passed and the Old Ones are no more. They
bequeathed the world and their relics to the ones… Well, whether it was the
ones...
Lycanthropes (1991)
-
From the back of the book:
"Lycanthropes is a 128-page sourcebook and 2 scenarios featuring werewolves
and the many other half-human, half-animal forms t...
Weird Fates Vol 1
-
By Laszlo Feher First Hungarian d20 Society OSR Levels 3-6 A cornucopia of
four short, open-ended adventure outlines leading to lands of pure
imagination, ...
d12 Main Cults For Strange Stars
-
My sf campaign is still at a system only and has no ftl yet, more like
Outland film or early Expance setting with first...
[REVIEW] Alchymystyk Hoosegow
-
*Alchymystyk HoosegowAlchymystyk Hoosegow (2023)*
by Alex Zisch
Self-published
Level 7 “with some fatalities”
Hello, and welcome to part SEVEN of **THE...
Minimalist "Weapon versus Armor" table
-
I've been talking about the weapons versus armor table for a while. And
brainstorming about weapons and armor in the last few days.
Here are a few random ...
Halloween Movies: Halloween (1978)
-
Last October I decided to start watching some of the classic horror movies
from the 70s and 80s that I missed as a kid, and I started with Nightmare
on E...
Non-rule Rules in my Campaigns
-
Someone asked on Enworld about informal conventions and customs in people’s
games that go beyond the mechanical rules of the game system, and it
occurred t...
Mythic Sparks
-
In Mythic Bastionland I have a bunch of prompts across the bottom of each
of the 72 Knight/Myth spreads, meaning you can roll a d6 and a d12 to get a
ran...
Autumn Is Gam(ing) Season...
-
No, not football. Tabletop roleplaying. It was autumn of 1977 when I fell
in love with the Rankin/Bass Hobbit, and autumn of 1979 when I found out we
wer...
Four Books on War
-
“ .. Belgium’s leading living poet whose life before 1914 had been a
flaming dedication to socialist and humanitarian ideals that were then
believed to e...
Classic Fantasy Imperative now available!
-
*Classic Fantasy* is the *Mythras* version of classic (1970s and 1980s) “*Dungeons
& Dragons*.” The “Imperative” version is a somewhat stripped-down version...
Mystery Solved
-
Last December I posted a message asking if anyone knew what the heck this
four-armed three-eyed weirdo was and today I noticed someone had an answer.
...
Into the Megadungeon
-
Just a quickie to let you know that if you're not following Ben Laurence's
new podcast Into the Megadungeon, you are doing yourself a serious
disservice....
Proxy? You Misspelled Patsy! Part 1
-
Mechane, Atomo and Spatia had a delightful little trade union going.
Things improved with time. Spatia's ships improved their drives and began
reaching ...
The Cult of Flesh (and the Three Great Gifts)
-
The Third Age
In the Beginning was the Authority, and his house was the Throne. In the
First Age he created the stars, but their songs disappointed him. In...
A Girl Called Samson - book review
-
I am going to deviate slightly from my usual gaming topic today. I have a
'mini book club' with a friend and she likes to read books I typically
would not...
Martel Tankette
-
This is a niche product if ever there was one — the 1925 wooden prototype
of the tiny one-man British *Martel *tankette.
The model is designed at 1:100...
The Fires of Lost Tlarba
-
A dense and dusty city toils under a flickering yellow sky. None may enter,
but everyone does. All may leave, but none do.
Prickly selks stand at the gat...
Arnecon
-
I've got a busy gaming schedule coming up. I'm playing in Virtual Greyhawk
con and running 2 games (Lakofka's Devils Dung and Lost Dungeons of
Tonisborg...
Playtest Session Recaps
-
Keeping it short and sweet:
*Session #1 (8/13/23): *Two brave novice adventurers - a half-elf
magic-user/cleric of the Far Wanderer and a gnome fighter/c...
OSR: Iron Gates Draft Content: The Arena of Rhen
-
The Iron Gates is an Alexander Romance / Dark Souls setting guide. After
years of (vague and unfocused) development, it's finally reached the point
where...
Change is in the air! I'm moving to Substack!
-
TLDR; Moving here: https://chgowiz.substack.com
I've been using Blogger, formerly Blogspot, since 2008, when I was at my
old blog http://oldguyrpg.blogs...
New! Book of Lost Tables
-
What’s this, a new book? Yes! The Book of Lost Tables is a revised and
expanded version of the Random Encounter and Terrain Generator. You can
find the det...
Free GM Resource: Dungeon X
-
[image: Free GM Resource: Dungeon X]
I came across this on Facebook and while it is a Free GM Resource, it's
also an ad (of sorts) for a Kickstarter than ...
The Dreams In Gary’s Basement Update
-
Pat Kilbane’s documentary of Gary Gygax and Dungeons and Dragons, The
Dreams In Gary’s Basement, was released online to Kickstarter backers
today. This mul...
On the OSR Christmas in July
-
Isn't it disappointing that only digital files are on sale at DTRPG?
So I've dropped the prices of print copies of my books!
Bestial Encounters Caused By...
Warsmith's Words: Preparing for 40K 10th edition
-
Welcome back to the Vault! Since my last post we've had the release of
10th edition, and I've spent a fair amount of time building the shiny new
models ...
Moving On...
-
So, my D&D 5e experiment has blown up the lab in a puff of green smoke
leaving my face blackened like Wile E. Coyote after a failed roadrunner
Acme trap...
Sorcery & Super Science! Bundle of Holding
-
Heya folks, we've got a quick-deal Bundle of Holding going on right now
that includes *ALL* (yes, you heard right) *ALL* of our Sorcery & Super
Science! ...
How to Keep Megadungeons Fresh
-
People often consider megadungeons boring. Not because the play style is
boring, but because they are in the same locale for a majority of the
campaign. If...
Random Encounters: Love Them!
-
Picture swiped for my own purposes from Random Encounter. I want this
sticker!
It's been a while since my last entry. More health issues. More computer...
Magical Magic That Feels Magical
-
*14. Heart Of The Beast: Cast this spell on a slain monster’s heart (or
reasonably equivalent organ or portion), then consume it. At any time, you
may ...
Flux Space
-
I’ve been inspired by my time working with Gus on Tombrobbers of the
Crystal Frontier, and want to play at making something similar: a big intro
adventure ...
The Blade Itself
-
I just finished listening to the audiobook of The Blade Itself, volume one
in Joe Abercrombie’s The First Law trilogy. This was my first exposure to
his wo...
Genteel Magistrate at FenCon XVIII
-
Victorious author Mike Stewart will be a guest at FenCon XVIII this weekend
at the Sheraton DFW Airport hotel, 4440 W. John Carpenter Freeway, Irving,
TX, ...
This is an Important Game Mechanic
-
*"That's the GM's Regional Map from my AOWG. And it's a damned good
regional map. It's not a good map for a Simple Homebrew Campaign. It does
some s$&...
Clean Your Room
-
Looking back at my little blog here. That last post… wow, I was having fun
playing WOW Classic! That was August of 1999 and I was having a blast… it
was ...
My RPG Zine Trilogy is on Kickstarter!
-
I can't believe I didn't post about it here!
The Dead are Coming, Screams Amongst the Stars and Running Out of Time are
on *Kickstarter right now!* Thes...
Maximum HP 004, one week to go
-
Just one week to go for Maximum HP issue #004, the undead. We are pushing
through stretch goals and wracking up contributions for the best issue yet.
We...
Steve Jackson Interview
-
James Maliszewski recently did an interview with Steve Jackson over on his
Grognardia blog. Steve chats about the beginnings of The Fantasy Trip and
upcomi...
Undermountain Map Origins
-
As documented on the Ruins of Undermountain sales page, "TSR didn't
actually use Ed Greenwood's original maps," at least not in their entirety.
This post d...
WB:FMAG Total Print Sales
-
Hello Folks,
The last time I did a quick sales report was in September 2018.
I pulled reports from Amazon, Lulu and DrivethruRPG from October to current
fo...
The Minotaur for Old-School Essentials
-
*Minotaur*
*Requirements:* Minimum STR 9, Minimum CON 9
*Prime Requisite:* STR and CON
*Hit Dice:* 1d10
*Maximum Level:* 8
*Armor:* Leather, including shield...
WIZARDS OF POHJOLA
-
Init +0
Melee Atk
• sword or dagger +1 (1d5 or 1d3)
Ranged Atk
• hot iron sparks +3 (1d4+2 to two targets within 20' but not closer than
5')
AC 14
HD 12d...
Dungeons & Dragonmead Fall Schedule
-
*As you know, I run public classic Dungeons & Dragons games at **The Loaded
Die**/Metro Detroit Game Night's Board Game Nigh at **Dragonmead**, in
Warren...
D&D Sling Damage vs. Large Targets
-
In many early editions of D&D, weapons were assigned two damage values: one
for small/medium targets (i.e. man-sized) and one for large targets (giants
and...
James A. Smith, Jr. Memorial Video
-
A beloved father, devoted friend, and D&D Dungeon Master extraordinaire. We
miss you! To view video, click here Memorial Video
Note - The original video...
Let's Talk About Pacing!
-
The idea, I think, is that the RPG is ultimately about the long game. Even
rolling back to the early days of Basic & Expert, the goal of the player
was...
Profane and Profound Prep Part 2
-
This is part 2 of my work to edit my magic items for a DMsGuild release,
along with adding cursed items along the way. Here is part 1. Bone of a
Saint 8000...
SHORT BREAK.
-
I'm going to take a break for a week or so and will start up again in the
New Year. Thanks for reading and we'll start with Level 6 when I get back.
Iain Lovecraft, 3D Sculptor
-
Nope, it's got nothing to do with Cthulhu. I just did a video conversation
with Iain Lovecraft, who designs 3D miniatures and terrain. If you're not
doi...
New website!
-
Slowly but surely, all the content here will make its way — in updated
form! — to my new website: timbannock.com. For fairly obvious reasons, that
site wil...
Please Update Your Link!
-
If you're seeing this, it means your link to the Greyhawk Grognard blog is
out of date.
Please update your link to www.greyhawkgrognard.com (RSS feed is
h...
Mord Mar - Session 6
-
We weren't able to play Mord Mar last week, due to a family funeral. This
week we played on Monday for the first time, due to kids returning to
school and ...
A Small, Quiet Plea
-
There has been a great deal of discussing political agendas, social
grievances, and personal attacks within the little corner of gaming that is
my hobby....
Don’t Sleep It’s Broken
-
Expanding/editing my comments from What Makes Something Broken G+ thread:
“Broken”, for me, is anything that makes normal character choices, tactics,
or ro...
Swords & Wizardry Light-Themed Birthday Party
-
Last month, my wife and I helped our oldest to celebrate his birthday in
style. Ever since 2013, we have hosted a themed birthday party for our
now-15-ye...
Structurally about the same. The rules have become more organized and perhaps legalistic in some ways -- I've seen some bits that basically clarify how the rules are supposed to work where someone found a loophole -- but overall I think more consistent. Fundamentally much is the same, it's mostly the particulars that have changed.
ReplyDeleteStill, Energy Blast is 5 points per d6 and Killing Blast is three times as expensive, and you can still build your powers the way you want, if you can afford them.
I think I'd argue that the complete rules above are actually a pretty bad way to learn the game. They are encyclopedic in their thoroughness, and don't lend themselves nearly so well to a new player as one of the smaller options - the Basic Rulebook, Champions Complete (if you want strictly supers), Monster Hunters International (for play in the world of Larry Correia's MHI) or the forthcoming Fantasy Hero (currently in Kickstarter with a $10 PDF entry point, with a focus on fantasy games, naturally).
ReplyDeleteThat's fair. These are reference books that are good to have, but they're not light reading.
DeleteI concur. I didn't get into HERO until the Sixth Edition and I found trying to learn the game with the two massive Sixth Edition tomes, collectively 1200 pages in length to be too daunting. I ending up getting the Basic Rulebook to learn the game and then reference the giant blue books when needed. Ultimately, I found getting into HERO like learning a new language. It's an endeavor not to be entered lightly, requires an commitment and an investment of time but once you get it, it's like a whole new world is open to you that you were excluded from before. Not sure if that helps but for ten bucks you really don't have much to lose. The great artwork in the HERO core is at least worth ten bucks so you'll get your money's worth regardless. As for needing a shit ton of books, you don't need anything beyond the core but once you crack the code, you'll want to get more than the core, so much more. When you consider that fifth and sixth edition are more or less the same thing, there are dozens and dozens of gloriously crunchy books to get. I now have over 50!
DeleteThe hero system is a beautifully balanced system. A work of art. Brutalist, modern art. Evocative and powerful and almost overwhelming in its perfectly balanced fury.
ReplyDeleteIt is one game where the mechanics jump off the page and can you by the throat and throttle you into awed supplication.
As a game, it's very dense and slow. If you like 4e, then you will nut yourself over Hero.
In other words, it's the Grape Nuts of RPGs.
I have over a hundred superheroes and supervillains lovingly constructed down to the last character point. Perfect works of art that do exactly what I mean for them to do mechanically. I could pull them out and play with any Hero group anywhere in the universe and in any century, and they would behave perfectly, like so many clockwork gnomes animated by a divine clockmaker.
And so these tiny works of art, each painstakingly crafted over hours and sometimes days, sit in a binder in a box under a table in my basement.
Maybe forever.
The game's the thing, man. And the game is slow, and doesn't suit my style.
The rules are slow. They are laid out very well. But they are so dense, you have to really want it to get the most out of the system.
There's no soul there. The rules have no soul. Nothing animates them.
Even in play, the GM can use them to make whatever he wants to. This is more true than in almost any other game system.
But instead of a world, it's a puppet show. The pieces all move exactly right. But there's no soul to it.
I have an incredibly deep admiration for Hero. I really, really, really want to love it. But instead of love, it's this really platonic deep respect.
The Hero System, it's destined to always live in my friend-zone.
Hero System is fundamentally the same game it was in the 80s. With expanded options and details. The new Champions book is a standalone game in its own right so I would start with that. Then use the main hero system book as a reference.
ReplyDeleteGet Hero Basic or Champions Complete (not on sale, unfortunately), and wait for Fantasy Hero Complete. Based on your schedule Erik I think you'll find little time to absorb the monstrosity that is the Hero 6th main books! I know I can't. That said I'll still probably get them for the hell of it.
ReplyDeleteDon't bother with any of this stuff, this is reference material for the die hard completist who wants every 'i' dotted and 't' crossed for them, and who has next to no imagination. The *only* book you need to run Hero games is *Champions Complete*. Although it is written with a superhero experience in mind, it is totally usable to run sci-fi, fantasy, modern espionage, whatever floats your boat. I used Champions 1e back in the day for precisely the same - all it takes it a little old school imagination.
ReplyDeleteI ran a Champions game for my old school fantasy group last summer, only one of whom had any experience with it, and that was from 20 years previously. The others approached with massive trepidation and foreboding as they had all heard how difficult Hero was, how mathematically intense it was, how it was crunch to the point of despair, but within 20 minutes they were all engrossed and couldn't believe how it had acquired such a bad rep. Half of them went and bought their own copies of *Champions Complete* over the next few days. Seriously.
That two page "everything you need to know about Hero" document really does distil the rules down to two pages. There is a single unified mechanic that anyone can explain / understand in 5 mins, then you're off. Character generation can be as light or intense as you like. Even complicated characters can be rattle off in 5 minutes using the excellent Hero Designer character software. However, for your typical fantasy characters there is no more to it than buy your stats, buy your skills, maybe a couple of talents (eidetic memory, etc), get some disadvantages, and a spell or two if you're that way inclined.
Now, I'm not saying this is an easy jump if you're a class 'n' level kind of guy who likes to know exactly what you get and when, with no messing around. However, if you're more at the RuneQuest / d100 end of the old school spectrum, it really is no more than that with the random stats replaced by a point buy system.
A bad ref can make any game system suck and be onerous to the players. Hero is no exception to that, but it is better at making bad refs worse, no question about it.
In summary, it really isn't as much of a big deal of a system as it's made out to be. Although Hero Games did try to make it one with the disastrous 6th Edition and nearly went under (deservedly) as a result. I reckon the *Fantasy Hero Complete* Kickstarter PDF is likely worth $10 of anyone's money.
Hope that helps with the informed choice thing :-)
I can't. I can't even sell it to me, and I'm a sucker for a huge discount.
ReplyDeleteHero is a really addictive character generating game that no one ever wants to play.
ReplyDeleteJust get a used copy of the 4th edition Big Blue Book. Every version since has been turned into law school textbook style and will make your eyes glaze over. So many Hero players believe in letter not spirit of the law, the writers feel they have to spell out every possible interpretation of any phrase, it's very "That depends on what 'is' is" in style.
ReplyDeleteI'm a lifetime (30+ yrs) Champions / HERO guy, but no fan of 6th Edition. In fact, I think it killed the line by being a flavorless, fix-what-isn't broken, overly-long monstrosity.
ReplyDeleteAnd after several false starts at teaching newbies the rules that went wonky (mostly slow combat, and rules munchkinery), I''ll never play with rookies again...which is no way to ensure the system grows and thrives.
Almost made a go of Fantasy Hero, but it was too much crunch for me to handle. Champions suffered from both complexity and imbalance, build your hero wrong and you are siting on you ass watching someone else finish the fight. Might pick up the .pdf anyway. At least as a .pdf it won't break my arm to pick it up.
ReplyDeletefoo... looks like the sale is already over.
ReplyDelete