Friday, September 22, 2017

Why I Say "Yes" Far More Often Than "No" as a DM at the Gaming Table

Last night at our FLGS (where I recently started running a Swords & Wizardry Light Campaign) we had an interested spectator who wanted to be a player.

"Can I convert my 5e Halfling Cleric to Swords & Wizardry?"


It was then pointed out to me that BtB, there are no Halfling Cleric PCs in SWL. I know, I wrote the rules. There also aren't Dwarven Clerics and the party already had one of those.

Give me a backstory that explains how and why you want to "break the rules as written" and its quite likely I'll go along with it. At the very least, I'll explain my rational for saying no if that's the case.

Gaming is as much about empowering the players as it about the actually game rules. Actually, empowering the players is probably the key to everyone having fun. I don't mean empowering by making their PCs more powerful but by allowing them to invest themselves into the campaign, because without player buy in you really don't have much of a campaign. So, most likely Yes to that class / race combo that isn't allowed by the book, but you better make an effort to sell me on it.

You want to try what? A running power leap into the door with strange metal swirly things and you're a halfling with 8 strength? Sure, roll a d20 and roll under strength. You have a penalty of 4 due to your size. 20? Great - you do that Wylie Coyote deal - you hit the door with a thump and hang there for a second before sliding to the floor.

Yes can lead to fun situations. No just leads to disappointment.


  1. "Yes, and..." is the THE BEST phrase to have in a DM's arsenal.

    1. I agree, always look to move along the story and try to heighten the fun. Time is precious, arguing at the table or squashing creativity will probably do more to kill a game than preserve game integrity. Our table, our rules. Just be able to communicate them to new players.

  2. Along with proper evil, nigh-maniacal laughter.

  3. At my last D&D session, a player gathered up some sulfur in cave. They later encountered a green slime that was slowly oozing towards them. That player thought maybe sulfur would be irritating to the green slime, so he spread some in its path.

    I had no reason to believe that green slimes were affected in any way, but it is early in the campaign, and I want to encourage creative thinking. The green slime recoiled and the players retreated safely. On top of that, green slimes in my campaign dislike sulfur, which adds just a little more flavor to them.


Tenkar's Tavern is supported by various affiliate programs, including Amazon, RPGNow,
and Humble Bundle as well as Patreon. Your patronage is appreciated and helps keep the
lights on and the taps flowing. Your Humble Bartender, Tenkar

Blogs of Inspiration & Erudition