Swords & Wizardry Light - Forum
First WotC 5e "Cease & Desist?"
Thanks to
+Tony T for the heads up.
Link to the post at
5e Spellbook Generator
Here's the text in full:
Dear Fellow RPG fans,
Thank you guys for supporting my work and spreading it out through the multiverse. I am glad it has gotten enough attention to have finally garnered a cease order from Wizards of the Coast.
Unfortunately, I would not like to make any real legal trouble to myself, so I have taken down the spellbook generator as it is. I will be providing (give me a week or so) the code as open source, not including any database with the spell information. If at any time, the Wizards decides to release an OGL for 5e, I will be more than happy to bring this back online.
I am really touched by how many people have sent me inquiries already about the spellbook generator. If you guys would like to continue to support the right and need for players to have tools such as this, feel free to email Wizards of the Coast and voice your concerns! As a DM and a player I wanted a tool in which to help my group out and together, a ton of you guys came and made that dream come true. As much as I understand why I was served a cease order, I am also saddened at the need for it. This generator did not help you play the game at all, it just made it so that you as a player could easily go through the beautiful content Wizards has provided. You still needed a PHB to play, so you've already given Wizards your money.
Good luck to all you gamers out there. This will not be the last you have heard of the spellbook generator! For other resources, feel free to check the about page. Use them until Wizards takes them down too!
Proudly,
Philip Vuong
*UPDATE* - Open source code available here.
NOTE TO WIZARDS - I am only open sourcing the code that I have written and own. I will not be distributing any underlying database or datasource containing the spell information to populate the application.
Tenkar's Tavern is supported by various affiliate programs, including Amazon, RPGNow, and Humble Bundle as well as Patreon. Your patronage is appreciated and helps keep the lights on and the taps flowing - Your Humble Bartender, Tenkar
Blogs of Inspiration & Erudition
-
Whisky and D&D 6th Edition
-
I like whisky.
The whisky industry is in an interesting moment: more whisky is being sold
around the world than ever before, and while this has caused cert...
45 minutes ago
-
Role Aids: Tower of Magicks
-
*From the back cover:*
*Years before, a demon lead horde assaulted the lone Tower. Now you must
enter the dread Tower where magic has gone wild to d...
57 minutes ago
-
[REVIEW] Sailors on the Starless Sea
-
Happy to meet you on the Starless Sea
*Sailors on the Starless Sea (2012)*
by Harley Stroh
Published by Goodman Games
0thlevel funnel for 15-20 characters o...
1 hour ago
-
DCC: Doom of the Savage Kings
-
Here we go. The band continues with an adventure that is second only to
the ultimate funnel and quintessential DCC adventure *Sailors on the
Starless Se...
3 hours ago
-
The Throne of the Gods
-
By Joseph Mohr 1e Levels 15+ Rumors have reached the adventurers about the
recent discovery of the legendary Throne of the Gods. This epic level
journey wi...
3 hours ago
-
The Exile
-
I'm writing another adventure. It was a small idea but it's already
spiraling out of "manageable" and into "I may never finish this".
Essentially: a sorce...
4 hours ago
-
Strahd: House of Durst, Dust, and Death...
-
Have you ever had a sprite stab you in the chest? Has that ever been the
best thing that’s happened to you that day?
I do not understand these people. The...
4 hours ago
-
OSR: The Grand GLOG Playtesting Review
-
The GLOG is Arnold K's fantasy heartbreaker homebrew. I've been using it
for, oh, ~50 sessions now. At ~4 hours a session that's 200 hours of
accumulated p...
6 hours ago
-
The Citadel at Nordvorn
-
Doug's new Kickstarter is live.
The Citadel at Nordvorn
13 hours ago
-
D&S
-
Players are expected to bitch and moan through the entire game that they'd
rather be out exploring a fantasy world.
17 hours ago
-
Cannibalistic Humanoid Underground Dicerollers
-
Have y'all seen the newest shirt being released by Exalted Funeral? It
combines gaming with one of my favorite b-horror flicks, C.H.U.D.! The art
was desig...
17 hours ago
-
Power Armoured Paint: Carcharodons Astra Intercessors
-
The Carcharodons Astra have returned from the depths of the Void to receive
welcome reinforcements in their unending war against the Xeno and the
Heretic. ...
18 hours ago
-
TBBYANR: The Wasted Lands
-
Whoa. A *Best Blog You Are Not Reading* post?
Yes! This is a feature I wanted to bring back for 2019 to give a shout out
to some lesser know, lesser read ...
20 hours ago
-
Harbinger Unheeded – Frank Mentzer Out at GaryCon
-
Today Gary Con’s Luke Gygax announced that Frank Mentzer will no longer be
an Guest of Honor at Gary Con. Luke’s post is linked above via the Gary Con
Face...
21 hours ago
-
The Citadel at Norðvorn Kickstarter
-
Douglas Cole over on Gaming Ballistic has just launched a Dungeon Fantasy
Kickstarter. A mini-setting called The Citadel at Norðvorn. If you like
viking t...
21 hours ago
-
Knight's Heraldry Generator
-
A simple heraldry generator for use with Hex Describe. Paste the below text
into the bottom box, type [heraldry] into the top box, and click submit.
Typ...
22 hours ago
-
Review & Commentary On Ford's Faeries: A Bestiary Inspired by Henry Justice Ford From Studio Kortex For Your Old School Campaigns
-
So I've been looking for a Dreamlands inspired monsters & stumbled across a
'free resource' for Original Dungeons & Dragons. That's when I stumbled
upon Fo...
1 day ago
-
Structures of the Apocalypse: Part 3
-
My companion to this is a city map of broken hill which is a almost city
capitol of the outback Australia. I want it to be sandbox city for...
1 day ago
-
Grills Gone Wild
-
This is a piece I designed for my own campaign, for use with 2d dungeon
tiles. It could also be used with 3d tiles, but I haven't sized it to fit
in with ...
1 day ago
-
Free GM Resource: Some Background Prelude to a History Lesson (Lesson not Included)
-
[image: Free GM Resource: Some Background Prelude to a History Lesson
(Lesson not Included)]
Ok, so this week...well specifically *today*, I'm phoning it in...
1 day ago
-
Eschatologies
-
To make anything very terrible, obscurity seems in general to be necessary.
When we know the full extent of any danger, when we can accustom our eyes
to it...
1 day ago
-
Mistakes and Community Expectations
-
I'm afraid this is another post completely devoid of game content, but a
rare post on the state of the RPG online community. In particular, this
relates to...
1 day ago
-
Are You Tired of Being Human and Good Posture?
-
Pruning spam from the comments is damn near a daily thing. It's not unusual
to wake and find some ad for Australian limos or alternative utility
companies...
1 day ago
-
Eldritch Foundry and the birth of Uud
-
The Gods of the Old World* have taken vengeance on me. After crapping on
(or constructively criticising) Games Workshops world-building like a
little rat, ...
2 days ago
-
Old-School Essentials: The Big "What's New" Post
-
So I've been going on about this *Old-School Essentials* thing recently,
which I'll be bringing to Kickstarter in a few months. As you are probably
aware, ...
2 days ago
-
New Reference & Handout Pack available for The Hyqueous Vaults
-
From the Better-Late-Than-Never Department, I just uploaded a Reference &
Handout Pack for The Hyqueous Vaults, that includes an un-keyed map for
virtual t...
2 days ago
-
Creating with Solar Blades & Cosmic Spells
-
I finally received my hardcover copy of Solar Blades & Cosmic Spells by Diogo
Nogueira of Old Skull Publishing. I've been reading through the PDF like
craz...
3 days ago
-
The OSR News: February 16, 2019
-
The return of the News Spotlight, a fist-full of One Page Dungeons and I
link something from Deadline Hollywood. Al Krombach makes an interesting
return t...
3 days ago
-
The Mouth of Spring
-
*In every town, village, and hamlet are women who have seen beyond fear,
who are strong enough to push back winter and bring new life to the lands.
Their p...
3 days ago
-
Crossing the Streams of Time and Space
-
Whenever I am at a loss about how to make my dreams for my Greatest
Campaign Ever™ closer to reality, I go back to reading old posts on Against
the Wicked ...
4 days ago
-
Star Trek X's First Eight
-
*These Are the Voyages: Mission Compendium Vol. 1* is an anthology of eight
ready-to-play adventures for use with Modiphius Entertainment’s Star Trek
Adve...
4 days ago
-
I Stand with Mandy.
-
If you haven’t yet, please read these much better accounts written by more
relevant figures. Nothing I can say will be as valuable as what they’ve
said. Ma...
4 days ago
-
Random friday
-
A bunch of things on my mind today.
First things first, our favourite anchorcaster Colin "Spikepit" Green
released his 100th episode! and it's absolutely f...
5 days ago
-
XRP in a Bundle of Holding
-
I'm pleased to say that our One on One Adventures Compendium is part of a Bundle
of Holding, the Bundle of Holding for Two #2.
This bundle focuses on games...
5 days ago
-
Plot Points…the reverse of Victory Points?
-
Greetings, First my apologies for over 2 weeks without a post. There were
extenuating circumstances, but in the end they are irrelevant. I am a
humble cur....
5 days ago
-
Our Game Spaces are a Reflection of Us
-
CW/TW - brief mention of sexual assault issues.
Yea, this post is because of the revelations of abuse by former girlfriends
Mandy, Vivka and Hannah of Zak ...
5 days ago
-
Lake Geneva Days, Still Writing
-
I have been spurred to remember--due to the recent explosion of those
accusing Zak S. of his many abuses--one of the reasons that I am writing *Lake
Geneva...
6 days ago
-
Building An Encouraging And supportive Community
-
I have been honored by some of my Twitter followers for my positive
presence there. On Twitter, I have been mentioned as one of the positive
influences i...
6 days ago
-
Party Roles for Players and Legacy Points
-
A friend of mine is writing a really great game centered around mercenary
guilds and how to handle them in an Old School RPG kind of way. His name is Feli...
6 days ago
-
Tolkien trailer
-
The first trailer for the forthcoming biopic of J.R.R. Tolkien is now
available for your viewing pleasure (all 55 seconds of it). You can watch
it, and rea...
1 week ago
-
Trap Tuesday - Outside the Dungeon
-
So far we have been talking about dungeon traps. But, traps are a wide and
varied subject. Today, we're going to talk about a different kind: the
political...
1 week ago
-
Top Dungeons and Dragons News
-
We should remember the past, lest. . .
If it were a fad, you wouldn't be reading about it right now.
Dungeons & Dragons was always a fast starter. The firs...
1 week ago
-
The TAGMAR universal table
-
Look at this beautiful thing (source):
It is an "universal" table (used for skills, combat, etc.) from the
Brazilian RPG Tagmar (supposedly based on Star ...
1 week ago
-
Unboxing Grimtooth’s Trapsylvania Kickstarter plus extras
-
The post Unboxing Grimtooth’s Trapsylvania Kickstarter plus extras appeared
first on IndyGaming.
1 week ago
-
Profane and Profound Prep Part 2
-
This is part 2 of my work to edit my magic items for a DMsGuild release,
along with adding cursed items along the way. Here is part 1. Bone of a
Saint 8000...
1 week ago
-
Dream Cover - In Search of the Unknown
-
Frank Frazetta was born this day February 9, 1928, in Brooklyn, NY. I'm
dedicating this "Dream Cover" post to him.
In Dream Cover posts I imagine being the...
1 week ago
-
Franklin Cascaes (1908 - 1983)
-
[image: 4 - invenção de contos]The Nightmare, 1969
[image: 4 - invenção de contos]O Boitata, 1968
[image: 4 - invenção de contos]Witch of the Modern Times,...
1 week ago
-
Nolenor Player’s Journal
-
I noticed today that my friend John of Damn Elf Press fame has started a
player’s journal for his Hero …
Continue reading →
1 week ago
-
A Great World map for Blackmoor
-
*....Dave Arneson decided to begin a medieval fantasy campaign game for his
active Twin Cities club. From the map of the "land" of the "Great Kingdom"
and ...
2 weeks ago
-
We Has Met the Enemy Part Four
-
With the Triumph en route to the Flying Dutchman, the Martian Admirals saw
an opportunity to at once cripple Earth's Asteroid Belt operations and
destroy t...
2 weeks ago
-
Exquisite Dungeon
-
Yesterday while we were waiting for some of the usual gang to arrive at The
Dungeon Tower FLGS it occurred to me that we were trying to run a long-run
ca...
2 weeks ago
-
Dungeons & Dragonmead Winter and Early Spring Schedule
-
*As you know, I run public classic Dungeons & Dragons games at **The Loaded
Die**/Metro Detroit Game Night's Board Game Nigh at **Dragonmead**, in
Warren, ...
3 weeks ago
-
D&D's 45th Birthday
-
Back when D&D turned 40 in 2014, I put up a post about the date I favored
for celebrating its anniversary: the last Sunday in January. Today, January
27,...
3 weeks ago
-
Random Terrain and Encounter Generator now Includes Cities, and Print
-
Huzzah! After many months of work, the print edition of BRW Games’ Random
Terrain and Encounter Generator is now available. We were holding off doing
the p...
3 weeks ago
-
[D&D] Reflecting on the Hall of Many Panes
-
Shortly after the turn of the century, Gary Gygax's posts to his email list
and on message boards began talking about a new adventure he was running in
his...
4 weeks ago
-
Last Post
-
I finally published my new website at,
https://www.gothridgemanor.com/blog
For those who have a blog roll, it would be cool if you could updated my
addre...
4 weeks ago
-
UPDATE 1 - Charting The Flanaess: a Settlements Distance and Mileage Chart
-
In May last year I began work on building a Settlements Distance and
Mileage Chart for the Flanaess, but the project has lain fairly fallow
until recently....
4 weeks ago
-
Battle Report: Warhammer 40K, Guards v. Orks
-
As we continue the odyssey of learning W40k live Jack and I fought mano a
mano where he had Orks and I had the IG.
We decided to leave doctrines and stra...
5 weeks ago
-
B/X Mummy Rot
-
I did not care for any of the versions of Mummy Rot I found around the web,
so I made my own B/X version. A little softer initially, and I think it
allows ...
5 weeks ago
-
The Elves of 74'...
-
As much as we like AD&D's multi-classing rules, they weren't exactly a
master class in technical elegance. But they weren't all that bad either
because; r...
1 month ago
-
Character Motivation in OD&D – More Than Murder-Hobos
-
A fundamental assumption in OD&D is that all player characters want
treasure (after all, it's the source of the vast majority of XP awarded).
But this does...
1 month ago
-
SHORT BREAK.
-
I'm going to take a break for a week or so and will start up again in the
New Year. Thanks for reading and we'll start with Level 6 when I get back.
1 month ago
-
WYVERN
-
Public Domain ImageInit +2
Melee Atk
• bite +4 (1d4 + poison)
• claw +1 (1d6+1)
AC 16HD 4d12
MV 60 fly 120
Act 1d20 + 1d16
SP gaze
Fort +7
Ref +6
Will ...
2 months ago
-
Tsillodeed of 0
-
So I saw this amazing picture a while back by my now favorite artist Dirk
Detweiler Leichty and immediately got this idea for an adventure which I
ran that...
2 months ago
-
Iain Lovecraft, 3D Sculptor
-
Nope, it's got nothing to do with Cthulhu. I just did a video conversation
with Iain Lovecraft, who designs 3D miniatures and terrain. If you're not
doin...
2 months ago
-
New website!
-
Slowly but surely, all the content here will make its way — in updated
form! — to my new website: timbannock.com. For fairly obvious reasons, that
site wil...
3 months ago
-
check this out
-
I am right now in a workshop on gamification in faculty development. I
just took this interesting quiz on gamer type:
https://gamified.uk/UserTypeTest2016...
3 months ago
-
Please Update Your Link!
-
If you're seeing this, it means your link to the Greyhawk Grognard blog is
out of date.
Please update your link to www.greyhawkgrognard.com (RSS feed is
h...
3 months ago
-
Review: Tiny Dungeon 2e
-
After reading *Eorathril *and *For Coin & Blood*, Gallant Knight Games has
really become a publisher I respect for their OSR work. Seriously, they do
OSR r...
4 months ago
-
Total Sales for WB:FMAG
-
Hi Folks,
It's been a long time since I provided an update for the sales of White
Box: Fantastic Medieval Adventure Game.
*LULU*
Print: 396
PDF: 433
*OBS*...
4 months ago
-
How can We Destroy this Campaign World?
-
d12
1. You must trick a bard into strumming the *Chords of Fate* on the *Lute
of Annihilation*
2. Legends tell of thermonuclear weapons beneath megadungeo...
4 months ago
-
My Recent Trip to the Land of Make Believe
-
Happy Friday to all the eyeballs that fall here! Let's start the day with
a fresh podcast, maybe something a bit longer, with two people having a
convers...
5 months ago
-
Mord Mar - Session 6
-
We weren't able to play Mord Mar last week, due to a family funeral. This
week we played on Monday for the first time, due to kids returning to
school and ...
5 months ago
-
A Small, Quiet Plea
-
There has been a great deal of discussing political agendas, social
grievances, and personal attacks within the little corner of gaming that is
my hobby....
7 months ago
-
E is for Earths
-
...of the parallel variety, that is.
I'd love for Light City to be accessible for all sorts of supers gaming. I
also just love a good, wacky multiverse. ...
10 months ago
-
Don’t Sleep It’s Broken
-
Expanding/editing my comments from What Makes Something Broken G+ thread:
“Broken”, for me, is anything that makes normal character choices, tactics,
or ro...
11 months ago
-
Publishing #9: Deploying the Open Game License
-
Unlike the earlier covers that cover your creative content, this covers the
boring-but-necessary-for-some-projects details on how to deploy the Open
Game L...
1 year ago
-
The Warlock's Tower
-
*F*or over eighty years, the Warlock lurked in his tower of stone, crafting
all manner of trinket and bauble for the many curious novice and veteran
travel...
1 year ago
-
Swords & Wizardry Light-Themed Birthday Party
-
Last month, my wife and I helped our oldest to celebrate his birthday in
style. Ever since 2013, we have hosted a themed birthday party for our
now-15-ye...
1 year ago
-
What Makes a Great Sandbox Adventure Great?
-
For going on six months now I have been doing an on-again/off-again
read/reread of favorite or suggested sandbox products. Unbidden the same
driving questi...
4 years ago
I can see both sides here
ReplyDeleteI played 2nd Ed for years before I owned any books, as my mother thought they were evil.
Lots of people who play never buy anything, especially with pdfs and downloads available.
At the same time, if I'm now allowed to share my tinkering with other people, then I'd rather play a different game which allows me to do that.
DeleteWhether or not WotC is in the "right," I'm personally much less inclined to spend money on them now.
A couple minutes of digging around strongly suggests that what this 5E Spellbook did was duplicate text from the book. That's not tinkering. That said....I think you would have been able to make a safe assumption that a product like this wasn't available legally to begin with, so other OGL-based games would have been better for you to begin with.
DeleteI can see WotC's reasons for the C&D, but I am firmly with LS; I have no interest in playing a game that doesn't allow you to support it. Take a look at the difference between WotC's response and Goodman Game's response - the Purple Sorcerer tools and the Reference Sheets/Books are made available with GG's blessing.
DeleteWotC could easily have offered some form of simple licensing agreement to allow what is, AFAICT, a "rapid generation of content" tool to remain available. After all, rapid generation of content is a good form of system support.
If the issue was simply the reproduction of spell content (and I assume that we are not talking reproduction of content in the already-free basic pdf?), then the tool could have been modified to delimit whatever WotC found objectionable. Again, in the GG model, spell results can all be accessed through the Crawler's Companion.
It's not a matter of "right" or "wrong", IMHO; it's a matter of what you are willing to pay for, and how much you want to control/share your material. The OGL made a ton of cool things possible, and I, for one, have no interest in stepping backwards from it.
(YMMV, of course!)
Copy text as written out of the rule book into an online resource is not "tinkering" but is outright copyright violation. I'm pretty liberal when it comes to fair use, but this was not.
DeleteThis guys site would print out a custom spellbook for you character from the actual lists and texts in the published Rulebooks.
DeleteI believe that this same function is a planned part of the online component for D&D that WotC has planned.
Ether wizards expects to create a similar product or they should buy him out and maybe hire him.
ReplyDeleteNot being familiar with the site, was he using the exact text of the spell descriptions from the Player's Handbook? That would make sense; even an OGL wouldn't allow you to use the exact text.
ReplyDeleteYeah I was wondering the same thing. Copying and pasting spell text from the book would be a bad idea. Making an OGL spell generator that coincidentally lists OGL spells also in the 5E book (but which does not duplicate spell rules or text) would be okay under the OGL, I think.
DeleteYes, the site would print exact copies of just the spells your character had.
DeleteA custom spellbook.
Having used the site, I can tell you it included the full text from the books for the spells, and generated reference cards, like in 4e, for your spellbook. From what I understand, he is able to offer the sourcecode, sans copywrited material like the spell text, from his website.
ReplyDeleteTechnically, this may not be the first C&D... It's just the first one that was made public.
ReplyDeleteThere was another guy who set up the 5e "SRD" web site that had large swaths of text copied from the Basic PDF. That came down in a matter of days. I'm pretty sure he got a C&D (or his host provider was sent a DMCA take down notice).
The real question is why are people buying into a 5th edition of D&D when there are already numerous other versions available, many for free.
ReplyDeleteI share your bafflement.
DeleteBecause it is "teh awesome". :)
DeleteSeriously though... It's D&D.
Brand is important because despite the dozens (if not hundreds) of OSR rules out there, finding a group to play "Gargoyles and Goblins" is a thousand-million times harder (even with the internet) than just going to the FLGS with a "D&D Players Wanted" flyer.
I went to one of the D&D Encounters events the other week and met 12 players playing 5e who could be potentially added to my group of players. No OSR game has evangelists pushing for public gaming events or other awareness campaigns. No OSR games show up in Barnes & Noble or other retail stores (or even a FLGS for that matter). Audience goes where the audience is.
Audience goes where the advertising draws them.
DeleteSame difference. :)
DeleteBecause early reviews indicate that it is a good game.
Delete