My players recovered an Efreeti Bottle last night in Rappan Athuk. Not having any desire for the party to have an Efreeti at their beck and call for a year and a day I had the Efreeti offer the opener of the bottle a wish.
I've never seen a game session come to a screeching halt faster in my life. They wanted to take a week to decide on the proper wish and it's wording. I wasn't going to stop them - I understand the importance, but I've never fucked a player over for a wish that didn't ask for it.
What I mean is this - in my mind, a wish is something that is appropriate for your relative level or a bit higher. So if you're level 7, something appropriate for a level 9 or 10 character, but if you are wishing for something appropriate for a 15th or 20th level character, it probably won't work out as you expect.
Sure, it's all rule of thumb, but my rule is basically "only screw the players if they are being extremely greedy or foolhardy."
That all being said, I'm very interested in seeing what the intervening week brings...
OSR Review & Commentary On Penney Tower By J.G. Desborough For The Wretched New Flesh Second Edition Rpg - " Penney Tower was just released at the Red Room store, @biggeekemporium and @GiantSlayerRPGs. It will be available later at http://Lulu.com in softcover. ...
3 hours ago