Monday, February 4, 2013

Letting Magic Items Fall Where They May - or - Sometimes the Cool Sh!t Just Never Gets Found

I enjoy making up cool and unique magic items that have both good and bad attributes. Most of the time, the good outweighs the bad, which makes for a nice, non-generic item for the player that finds it.

When I decided to use Rappan Athuk, I knew I wanted to swap in some of my creations. My party has done a decent job of missing a handful. They almost missed the last one they found. I had to reread to them a "player's note" they had stumbled across 2 weeks earlier real time, but maybe a day game time.

See, I've been running games via G+ Hangouts and (the soon to be no more) Tabletop Forge. It was a pretty decent combination, except that you had to redraw the map with each session and there is no way to give players an actual "handout". What should have been a fair clue was forgotten over the intervening weeks. So, the other week I reminded them of their "handout". They were able to overcome (and then release and run from, foolish party) their adversary, but not before one of the party's thieves found an item I had placed weeks prior.

Strangely enough, it was the one section of the second level that they had bypassed when moving on to the third, before backtracking.

I have no problem letting my creations "rot away" unfound. It's the nature of fate. If they weren't hard to find in the first place, they wouldn't be as memorable ;)

I expect forgotten player's handouts will not be an issue in the future. Last weekend, before the announced merge of TTF into Roll20, I'd already decided to give Roll20 a shot. In part, it was for the mapping with a decent Fog of War, but it was also for the Player's Handouts feature. I expect I'll be giving both features a decent workout in the coming weeks.


  1. my players are terrible at cleaning up dungeons - leaving most leaders chance to flee with cool stuff. My next royal dungeoneeers game ill be doing scenarios like clean up after real heroes and quick deep dungeon probe missions where speed is the essence(a wizard has gone rogue and we need him dead)- They did amass a whole house of depraved evil furniture though - go figure?

  2. I use a free blogspot blog for each campaign, as well as the game platform if it's online. Easy to upload handouts to the blog, and a couple players might even read them! :)

  3. Letting things be missed is an important part of the experience, IMHO. I always try to seed enough cool stuff that if 20-25% of it goes unfound, the game is still fun.

    Without missed stuff, there is no tension in searching, either tension about spending the time to do so (which involves risk), or tension about whether or not you have found all there is to find.


Tenkar's Tavern is supported by various affiliate programs, including Amazon, RPGNow,
and Humble Bundle as well as Patreon. Your patronage is appreciated and helps keep the
lights on and the taps flowing. Your Humble Bartender, Tenkar

Blogs of Inspiration & Erudition