This is the opposite question of last night's topic, but I think it's just as valid:
Which of the RPG settings that you've played in / run / read did you like the least?
For me, it's Council of Wyrms. I read this, so it as a power gamer's heaven (and a DM's nightmare) and promptly put it on the bottom of my gaming pile. Shit, I haven't cracked the box open since then.
As fractalbat said below about Ravenloft, I like some of the individual pieces of the WOD (the Mages and mummies, for example). But taken as a whole, I agree, it's just too much. Plus I really don't like the Storyteller system.
Have to be forgotten realms. As originally released it was okay...kind of bland, but okay. Unfortunately the realms became the default dumping ground for every moronic idea and shameless moneygrab that TSR could dream up during the late 80's. And so it eventually became an insane themepark of excess, and not in a good way.
Ouch, hatin' on Dragonlance and the Realms over here! Well, if you ask me, both of those worlds at least took more imagination to create, or OVER-create for those who think so, than Mystara, which is my pick for most disliked setting. It gets a lot of hype but I've never really understood that phenomenon. It had some interesting ideas here and there, but overall it seemed uninspired. For one thing, even for a fantasy world, the geography and climates made no sense. For another, there was the barest of efforts to hide the fact that the Mystaran nations were directly ported over from real-world analogues. Really the only good thing ever to come out of Mystara was the Voyage of the Princess Ark series.
Princess ark i didn't like - i like the world never like name (a competition winner) - gazetteers great and plenty of room for dm to move unlike every other tsr world
Glorantha, I loved RuneQuest but the bronze age with everyone having magic and humanoid ducks was hard to get my brain around. Houseruled the heck out of the rules and transfered it to Hârn and I was happy.
If you break Ravenloft up into it's components I like it. Each domain taken individually is something I could see running a game in.
Taken as a whole as presented in the box set? It's an excess of horror tropes that doesn't work. What makes the Hammer Horror Film thing work is its opposition to the mundane, but in Ravenloft it IS the mundane.
When horror is all there is, it's no longer horror.
I agree strongly about Ravenloft and Hammer Horror. HH is based on Victorian horror tropes, darkness in the light. An intrusion of evil into Merrie Englande, or the Count's castle squirreled away on the edge of civilised Europe, or devil worshippers on Guernsey. Total opposite of the Gnostic setup of Ravenloft and Masque of the Red Death where evil is all-pervasive.
"When horror is all there is, it's no longer horror."
I think this is a very common mistake where game designers (and authors, film makers, etc.) try to make their work relentlessly "dark" by omitting all humor, pathos, and positive emotions. What they don't seem to realize is that they thereby lose all contrast, and the effect is nil. You can't write in black ink on black paper and expect to convey any kind of message.
Is it actually power gaming if every thing you encounter is equal to or stronger than the party?
Dragonlance has always sucked. Even the first three novels were terrible to try and read. Though they are high lterature compared to the Halfling's Gem, yeech!
There are too many terrible settings to count, but I think Valdorean Age (Hero System I think) was the most disappointing - cover advertises it as a wild Conanesque setting, inside is a 1990s fantasy city of Political Correctness and boredom.
I guess few settings beat that of Cyborg Commando for awfulness, though. :)
As to D&D settings I dislike, well I really don't like Eberron at all, and Dark Sun takes away all the things I like about Sword & Planet romance (the 4e DS monster book would be great, though, for a John Carter type setting). But I'm willing to accept that's just personal taste.
I'd have to say Mage the Awakening. The new age occult just doesn't jive with the rest of the World of Darkness for me. It might be fine asa pure fantasy setting but when put aside Werewolf the Forsaken and Vampire the the Requiem it rubs me the wrong way. It doesn't help that I can't stand the formatting of the core book.
I actually love Council of Wyrms. It's pretty much the only second ed setting I still play on occasion.
Dragonlance, the Ansalon part. Most of the clichés people ascribe to Tolkien actually originated here. All cultures present are boring. Kender are stupid. So are Tinker gnomes. I hate how the tinker somehow became the "standard" gnome. However, I really like Taladas, as presented in the "Time of the Dragon" boxed set. The descriptions in that set were a bit dry, but the world is awesome.
I used to hate the Realms, but in reality I hated the characters and the hype it got. There are a lot of things I hate about Dragonlance too (gully dwarves, kender and gnomes) but not everything.
But in truth I do hate any of them or even dislike. The worst I can about a world it that it doesn't inspire me.
Krynn. It's just way too cutesy for me, and what isn't cutesy is stupid or drenched in religious overtones. I really don't like Tracy Hickman's work in general, especially not his fiction. In fact, I blame him personally for the entire genre of gaming fiction, which is almost invariably horrible to read.
Hmm, for the longest time it was Harn, but I've changed my mind about it. I think any setting that is a book first then made into a setting. Like Kyrnn and Middle Earth. They just don't jive for me because they always seem desperate to stay true to the books even if makes the RPG experience suffer.
That said, I love the Thieves World setting and the books. So I just contradicted myself.
Early Forgotten realms was an ok psuedo tolkien world with some nice bits to steal - i didnt mind some of the region books (Jaquay one works as griffin mountain add on) - last TSR product i got was undercity - wild magic and killing gods made me lose interest - just got worse and worse - TSR strange psuedo history phaze of early 90s did so many lame things like marco polo, terrible aztec products, central asia and stuff hopelessly inferior to real history books which i got into because it was cheaper and better - Herodotus was more awesome than any game book ever. Mystara and realms killed by lazy real world rip offs. Glaantri book with venice type city was inspired exception though. Names based on history embarrassing bad.
Da Realms. Others have given the basics: bland and meh but workable at first, then got every stupid idea TSR could muster. Throw in the creator's pet Elmunchkin and the fact that it's so big that it is hard to get a handle on it.
Love anything Gygaxian, not just Greyhawk but products from Necromancer Games and other serious gaming systems like Rune Quest (mostly) and Ars Magica.
FR because the awesome artwork sucked you into a vomit of high magic and unending expensive inane products. A brightly polished money-grab.
DL because of the Kender, and the Gully Dwarves, and every thinly obscured theft from other fantasy worlds and the real world.
Eberron because it was simply a hack mash-up that had nothing unique about it. Except perhaps the Dragon Prophecy and that was a topic about which PCs were very unlikely to know or learn anything significant - ever. That and it was so PC (politically correct) that it made you want to puke.
Anything 4th Ed D&D.
The Battle Grid (3.x D&D) as it hamstrings everything fun or spontaneous about the game... unless you're a munchkin Rules Lawyer.
And to answer your question: No, I never played CoW. The cover art was a sufficient warning for me to avoid it. Mystara too btw. Yes, there are so many games to hate on.
But mostly I hate growing up, getting out of college (with degree in hand), and live-action role-playing being an adult. This world may suck the worst of all of them. Thank you al qaeda and all those groups of people not so very different from you. You make this world suck and blow at the same time.
Omens
-
(Note: This was written a week ago, before the current playtest release of
Primeval Bastionland)
Like the dreamlike mists that cloak its landscape, *Prim...
Complete Divine
-
From the back of the book:
Weild Power Granted By The Gods
Legends tell of brave champions whose unwavering faith earned them the
favor of the gods. emp...
The Tomb of the Twins
-
By Luke Simonds Cats Have No Lord Black Hack 2e The Tomb of the Twins is a
mini-dungeon designed for use with The Black Hack 2e system. It is a small
dunge...
Story Gaming the Old School?
-
Tabletop roleplaying's traditional form involves a sharp division of labor.
Conan, for all his might, had little control over the enemies he fought,
only...
Informal Survey Results
-
Last week I posted an informal survey across my social media, “What is the
one thing you wish your DM did?” The question came up after I had watched a
vide...
OSR: Class: Cheese Wizard
-
One of my players misread "Curse-Eater Wizard" as "Cheese-Eater Wizard" and
was disappointed at the lack of cheese. Here's a GLOG class.
Cheese Mites, 19...
It's July!
-
I can't believe it is July already. I don't have an overall theme for this
month except to get to some games I have wanted to try out. Not sure if
thos...
Esekar Sector Map
-
Blue – Trade Ports Yellow – Mining Planets Green – Colony Worlds Red – Fuel
Stations While it is still somewhat of a tossup between Scum and Villainy
and S...
June '22 in Review
-
Poison Ivy Sucks! This has unfortunately been the main theme of the second
half of the month, and it’s been a busy month too. One of the joys of
having a...
Free GM Resource: The Mines of Khunmar
-
[image: Free GM Resource: The Mines of Khunmar]
I've had this saved for a hot minute and just this morning managed to
actually download and give a quick s...
Miskatonic Monday #123: Cat’s Cradle
-
Between October 2003 and October 2013, Chaosium, Inc. published a series of
books for *Call of Cthulhu* under the Miskatonic University Library
Associati...
The Athabasca Fold Network
-
*Memorize this, but for god's sake don't act like you know it. Play dumb
and ask for directions like everyone else or you'll get flagged and dumped
out a...
Music Monday - New America
-
It's Independence Day here in the states and given recent judicial rulings,
violence against LGBT+ groups, and calls for censorship (some of which I've
bee...
Felltower & the (in)ability to study
-
Thinking about the experience system in Traveller, and Felltower, it occurs
to me that they're two completely different ways to go about it.
In Traveller, ...
Pestilential Painting: Chaos Spawn completed
-
Welcome back to the Vectorium! The summer of Chaos is truly upon us; the
Chaos Space Marine Codex is *finally* here, and I've been poring over the
book....
Gamelog: Finished tombs and against the snake folk
-
Our Heroes:
7th Lv Fighter - Barbarian Archer Lord seeking glory and battle, talks to
birds
-Personal Priestess
-Mastif war dog abhumanoid (Mostly guards...
Update and Thoughts on Blogging
-
Just a quick update, and an apology for those of you who had a flurry of
blog update notifications today …
Continue reading →
[ZINE] Echoes From Fomalhaut #10 (NOW AVAILABLE!)
-
Guests of the Beggar KingI am pleased to announce the publication of the
tenth issue of my fanzine, *Echoes From Fomalhaut*. This is a 52-page zine
dedic...
So You Want to be a Pirate: Spec For
-
I got into the how and why of piracy. Let me talk about about space future
pirates!
You are not merely a *pirate*. You are a pirate in space *AND *in th...
Why D&D?
-
Very often - Monday's post is an obvious example - I will post an idea on
the blog for a campaign I'd like to run or a book I'd like to write, and
people...
I Played King of Dragon Pass
-
(in response to the comments in this post) and I was not that good at it,
and then did ok. But then got bored. But I learned a lot and now have much
more s...
Finding spells is better than choosing them
-
D&D is probably my favorite RPG nowadays - mostly in the OSR versions, but
even 5e sometimes. But one of the things I dislike the most about it is
picking ...
Reflection and Formation
-
There are many broad functions that rules can have. Here is one:
representing the details of a broader fictional world. The fictional world
might not work ...
Why Dragons Should Never Lose
-
Back in the 'aughts, WotC had a forum set up for folks to discuss D&D. I
yoinked this little tidbit from one of the user profiles on that old (and
eithe...
Helvéczia: Journal de Campagne, 3
-
We resumed play this past week, joining the company still within the
farmstead where those that remain of the seven knaves are restrained or
incapacitate...
The NTRPG Con 2022 Victorious game: Part 1
-
At the beginning of the session we passed out envelopes to each of the
seven players. They were told to open them and look at the 2 playing cards
within. I...
Desert War in 1:150 Scale
-
For no particular reason, except my customary inability to stick to a
project, I thought I'd try printing some desert stuff in 1:150 scale (10mm)
just...
Missing google drive files & reorganization
-
Hey everyone, recently google drive changed the way permissions are done.
Because of this I am continually getting requests for previous files from
post...
Orcs and Beastmen, Part 1
-
*Note: Oddly enough, Bar Chakka was part of my very first draft of
Centerra, back in 2010. Centerra has changed a lot in the last 12 years,
but two mos...
Mega-Dungeon Map Design Sprints with Henry
-
*Update - 13 June 2022 at 7:18pm*: Well, just like my lost big posts
during Kellri's Module Challenge, blogger crapped out and I lost this huge
post de...
Text Folding Tool for Referee Notes
-
Organizing campaign notes is frustrating. My preference would be to keep
all my hobby material in an analog format, but it’s not practical. A
campaign is a...
Education, Fleshing out a System
-
A little over I year ago I posted on the value of an education system in
your old school game. What follows is some further exploration of the idea
and...
Wyrdwood Adventures, ep12
-
The following is a solo adventure I am running using White Box FMAG, the
Perilous Wilds, Freebooters on the Frontier and Into the Wyrd and Wild. I
use my o...
On Ecology Completed
-
So that happened.
Bestial Ecosystems created by Monster Inhabitation is out.
I'm getting better at it. There was something off about the softcovers, so...
Plugging Away
-
As of a month ago I'm now working again on a part-time basis (three days a
week). In January I walked away from a position I'd held for over 20 years
bec...
Back in the Day: Playing The Never Used Rules
-
As most everyone who finds this obscure blog knows I started playing
OD&D in 1977 and switched to AD&D 1e in 1979 and have been playing 1e ever
since....
E'a, Chronicles of a Dying World
-
David M. Fitzgerald's *E'a: Chronicles of a Dying World *is one of the more
obscure digest-sized unofficial supplements to early D&D, little known even...
Random Research
-
This post was prompted by two players having questions that required NPCs
to do research. One PC is a cleric, the other a paladin. They worship
different...
Ivan Reitman, 1946-2022
-
I didn't want too much more time to pass before posting something here in
tribute to filmmaker Ivan Reitman, who the world lost unexpectedly on
Saturday,...
Vox Machina: Good for a Few Laughs
-
TL;DR: it’s ok.
How’s that for brief?
Ok, seriously, it’s got some fun moments, but isn’t nearly as clever as it
thinks it is. Better?
Dig...
Julius Moessel (1871 - 1957)
-
[image: Julius Moessel - Symphony in Hell, No. 2, 1940's]Symphony in Hell,
No. 2, 1940's
[image: Julius Moessel - Symphony in Hell (No.3)]Symphony in He...
Growling Mage Tavern
-
The other day I used Frog God Games *Journey Generator*. There was a set of
tables to create an inn or tavern. So I rolled up one because you can never
...
Clean Your Room
-
Looking back at my little blog here. That last post… wow, I was having fun
playing WOW Classic! That was August of 1999 and I was having a blast… it
was ...
People of the World, Spice up Your Life
-
I have seen the *Dune*. It’s good, but, like all “content” now, too long.
The forms of many designs are quite nice (love the costumes of the imperial
de...
What's wrong with megadungeons?
-
I ran across a megadungeon article from last July. I know, I am a little
behind, as I was dealing with my cancer when it came out.
In the blog, DM David ...
My RPG Zine Trilogy is on Kickstarter!
-
I can't believe I didn't post about it here!
The Dead are Coming, Screams Amongst the Stars and Running Out of Time are
on *Kickstarter right now!* Thes...
Maximum HP 004, one week to go
-
Just one week to go for Maximum HP issue #004, the undead. We are pushing
through stretch goals and wracking up contributions for the best issue yet.
We...
Steve Jackson Interview
-
James Maliszewski recently did an interview with Steve Jackson over on his
Grognardia blog. Steve chats about the beginnings of The Fantasy Trip and
upcomi...
Undermountain Map Origins
-
As documented on the Ruins of Undermountain sales page, "TSR didn't
actually use Ed Greenwood's original maps," at least not in their entirety.
This post d...
A Campaign Begins for Newbies
-
Like many of you, the affects of the Coronavirus pandemic has disrupted how
hundreds of millions of us fellow mutants interact and function in our
jobs, co...
WB:FMAG Total Print Sales
-
Hello Folks,
The last time I did a quick sales report was in September 2018.
I pulled reports from Amazon, Lulu and DrivethruRPG from October to current
fo...
The Minotaur for Old-School Essentials
-
*Minotaur*
*Requirements:* Minimum STR 9, Minimum CON 9
*Prime Requisite:* STR and CON
*Hit Dice:* 1d10
*Maximum Level:* 8
*Armor:* Leather, including shield...
WIZARDS OF POHJOLA
-
Init +0
Melee Atk
• sword or dagger +1 (1d5 or 1d3)
Ranged Atk
• hot iron sparks +3 (1d4+2 to two targets within 20' but not closer than
5')
AC 14
HD 12d...
Strange, Dangerous, and Inhuman: The Fey and Fairie
-
When I was a boy I loved fairy tales. Jack and the Beanstalk, Puss in
Boots, Rumpelstiltskin - I devoured all of it. My fascination that there
was a strang...
Dungeons & Dragonmead Fall Schedule
-
*As you know, I run public classic Dungeons & Dragons games at **The Loaded
Die**/Metro Detroit Game Night's Board Game Nigh at **Dragonmead**, in
Warren...
D&D Sling Damage vs. Large Targets
-
In many early editions of D&D, weapons were assigned two damage values: one
for small/medium targets (i.e. man-sized) and one for large targets (giants
and...
James A. Smith, Jr. Memorial Video
-
A beloved father, devoted friend, and D&D Dungeon Master extraordinaire. We
miss you! To view video, click here Memorial Video
Note - The original video...
Let's Talk About Pacing!
-
The idea, I think, is that the RPG is ultimately about the long game. Even
rolling back to the early days of Basic & Expert, the goal of the player
was...
Profane and Profound Prep Part 2
-
This is part 2 of my work to edit my magic items for a DMsGuild release,
along with adding cursed items along the way. Here is part 1. Bone of a
Saint 8000...
SHORT BREAK.
-
I'm going to take a break for a week or so and will start up again in the
New Year. Thanks for reading and we'll start with Level 6 when I get back.
Iain Lovecraft, 3D Sculptor
-
Nope, it's got nothing to do with Cthulhu. I just did a video conversation
with Iain Lovecraft, who designs 3D miniatures and terrain. If you're not
doin...
New website!
-
Slowly but surely, all the content here will make its way — in updated
form! — to my new website: timbannock.com. For fairly obvious reasons, that
site wil...
Please Update Your Link!
-
If you're seeing this, it means your link to the Greyhawk Grognard blog is
out of date.
Please update your link to www.greyhawkgrognard.com (RSS feed is
h...
How can We Destroy this Campaign World?
-
d12
1. You must trick a bard into strumming the *Chords of Fate* on the *Lute
of Annihilation*
2. Legends tell of thermonuclear weapons beneath megadungeo...
Mord Mar - Session 6
-
We weren't able to play Mord Mar last week, due to a family funeral. This
week we played on Monday for the first time, due to kids returning to
school and ...
A Small, Quiet Plea
-
There has been a great deal of discussing political agendas, social
grievances, and personal attacks within the little corner of gaming that is
my hobby....
Don’t Sleep It’s Broken
-
Expanding/editing my comments from What Makes Something Broken G+ thread:
“Broken”, for me, is anything that makes normal character choices, tactics,
or ro...
Swords & Wizardry Light-Themed Birthday Party
-
Last month, my wife and I helped our oldest to celebrate his birthday in
style. Ever since 2013, we have hosted a themed birthday party for our
now-15-ye...
World of Darkness. Or Dragonlance. Either one, really.
ReplyDeleteAs fractalbat said below about Ravenloft, I like some of the individual pieces of the WOD (the Mages and mummies, for example). But taken as a whole, I agree, it's just too much. Plus I really don't like the Storyteller system.
DeleteForgotten Realms.
ReplyDeleteKrynn, by a long way.
ReplyDeleteStar Bores. I mean Wars.
ReplyDeleteDid you hate it prior to 1999? I find I now have to struggle to remember that there were once GOOD Star Wars movies.
DeleteHave to be forgotten realms. As originally released it was okay...kind of bland, but okay. Unfortunately the realms became the default dumping ground for every moronic idea and shameless moneygrab that TSR could dream up during the late 80's. And so it eventually became an insane themepark of excess, and not in a good way.
ReplyDeleteOuch, hatin' on Dragonlance and the Realms over here! Well, if you ask me, both of those worlds at least took more imagination to create, or OVER-create for those who think so, than Mystara, which is my pick for most disliked setting. It gets a lot of hype but I've never really understood that phenomenon. It had some interesting ideas here and there, but overall it seemed uninspired. For one thing, even for a fantasy world, the geography and climates made no sense. For another, there was the barest of efforts to hide the fact that the Mystaran nations were directly ported over from real-world analogues. Really the only good thing ever to come out of Mystara was the Voyage of the Princess Ark series.
ReplyDeletePrincess ark i didn't like - i like the world never like name (a competition winner) - gazetteers great and plenty of room for dm to move unlike every other tsr world
DeleteGlorantha, I loved RuneQuest but the bronze age with everyone having magic and humanoid ducks was hard to get my brain around. Houseruled the heck out of the rules and transfered it to Hârn and I was happy.
ReplyDeleteLeast favorite...
ReplyDeleteIf you break Ravenloft up into it's components I like it. Each domain taken individually is something I could see running a game in.
Taken as a whole as presented in the box set? It's an excess of horror tropes that doesn't work. What makes the Hammer Horror Film thing work is its opposition to the mundane, but in Ravenloft it IS the mundane.
When horror is all there is, it's no longer horror.
I agree strongly about Ravenloft and Hammer Horror. HH is based on Victorian horror tropes, darkness in the light. An intrusion of evil into Merrie Englande, or the Count's castle squirreled away on the edge of civilised Europe, or devil worshippers on Guernsey. Total opposite of the Gnostic setup of Ravenloft and Masque of the Red Death where evil is all-pervasive.
Delete"When horror is all there is, it's no longer horror."
DeleteI think this is a very common mistake where game designers (and authors, film makers, etc.) try to make their work relentlessly "dark" by omitting all humor, pathos, and positive emotions. What they don't seem to realize is that they thereby lose all contrast, and the effect is nil. You can't write in black ink on black paper and expect to convey any kind of message.
Good point about Ravenloft, with regard to making the horrific commonplace...
DeleteIs it actually power gaming if every thing you encounter is equal to or stronger than the party?
ReplyDeleteDragonlance has always sucked. Even the first three novels were terrible to try and read. Though they are high lterature compared to the Halfling's Gem, yeech!
There are too many terrible settings to count, but I think Valdorean Age (Hero System I think) was the most disappointing - cover advertises it as a wild Conanesque setting, inside is a 1990s fantasy city of Political Correctness and boredom.
ReplyDeleteSpelljammer for sure
ReplyDeleteI guess few settings beat that of Cyborg Commando for awfulness, though. :)
ReplyDeleteAs to D&D settings I dislike, well I really don't like Eberron at all, and Dark Sun takes away all the things I like about Sword & Planet romance (the 4e DS monster book would be great, though, for a John Carter type setting). But I'm willing to accept that's just personal taste.
I'd have to say Mage the Awakening. The new age occult just doesn't jive with the rest of the World of Darkness for me. It might be fine asa pure fantasy setting but when put aside Werewolf the Forsaken and Vampire the the Requiem it rubs me the wrong way. It doesn't help that I can't stand the formatting of the core book.
ReplyDeleteI actually love Council of Wyrms. It's pretty much the only second ed setting I still play on occasion.
Harn
ReplyDeleteForgotten Realms. Too much of a vanilla D&D kitchen-sink.
ReplyDeleteDragonlance, the Ansalon part. Most of the clichés people ascribe to Tolkien actually originated here. All cultures present are boring. Kender are stupid. So are Tinker gnomes. I hate how the tinker somehow became the "standard" gnome.
ReplyDeleteHowever, I really like Taladas, as presented in the "Time of the Dragon" boxed set. The descriptions in that set were a bit dry, but the world is awesome.
FR
ReplyDeleteI used to hate the Realms, but in reality I hated the characters and the hype it got.
ReplyDeleteThere are a lot of things I hate about Dragonlance too (gully dwarves, kender and gnomes) but not everything.
But in truth I do hate any of them or even dislike. The worst I can about a world it that it doesn't inspire me.
Even if it seems all too obvious-- Forgotten Realms, for all the reasons already mentioned.
ReplyDeleteKrynn. It's just way too cutesy for me, and what isn't cutesy is stupid or drenched in religious overtones. I really don't like Tracy Hickman's work in general, especially not his fiction. In fact, I blame him personally for the entire genre of gaming fiction, which is almost invariably horrible to read.
ReplyDeleteEberron. Steam punk magic ugh!
ReplyDeleteHmm, for the longest time it was Harn, but I've changed my mind about it. I think any setting that is a book first then made into a setting. Like Kyrnn and Middle Earth. They just don't jive for me because they always seem desperate to stay true to the books even if makes the RPG experience suffer.
ReplyDeleteThat said, I love the Thieves World setting and the books. So I just contradicted myself.
Forgotten Realms. And Krynn.
ReplyDeleteRavenloft. I've never understood why D&D should be used for a pseudo-Victorian setting.
ReplyDeleteEarly Forgotten realms was an ok psuedo tolkien world with some nice bits to steal - i didnt mind some of the region books (Jaquay one works as griffin mountain add on) - last TSR product i got was undercity - wild magic and killing gods made me lose interest - just got worse and worse - TSR strange psuedo history phaze of early 90s did so many lame things like marco polo, terrible aztec products, central asia and stuff hopelessly inferior to real history books which i got into because it was cheaper and better - Herodotus was more awesome than any game book ever. Mystara and realms killed by lazy real world rip offs. Glaantri book with venice type city was inspired exception though. Names based on history embarrassing bad.
ReplyDelete+Eric Tenkar, to your original question: Yes, not me but there is a very popular running on the setting over at roleplayinggames.net.
ReplyDeleteAs for person hated settings and I'm sure some people in the community will wish to kill me for this: Gamma World.
Da Realms. Others have given the basics: bland and meh but workable at first, then got every stupid idea TSR could muster. Throw in the creator's pet Elmunchkin and the fact that it's so big that it is hard to get a handle on it.
ReplyDeleteI solved the Bigness problem by simply halving all distances. :)
DeleteForgotten Realms, because all of the extra baggage.
ReplyDeleteLove anything Gygaxian, not just Greyhawk but products from Necromancer Games and other serious gaming systems like Rune Quest (mostly) and Ars Magica.
ReplyDeleteFR because the awesome artwork sucked you into a vomit of high magic and unending expensive inane products. A brightly polished money-grab.
DL because of the Kender, and the Gully Dwarves, and every thinly obscured theft from other fantasy worlds and the real world.
Eberron because it was simply a hack mash-up that had nothing unique about it. Except perhaps the Dragon Prophecy and that was a topic about which PCs were very unlikely to know or learn anything significant - ever. That and it was so PC (politically correct) that it made you want to puke.
Anything 4th Ed D&D.
The Battle Grid (3.x D&D) as it hamstrings everything fun or spontaneous about the game... unless you're a munchkin Rules Lawyer.
And to answer your question: No, I never played CoW. The cover art was a sufficient warning for me to avoid it. Mystara too btw. Yes, there are so many games to hate on.
But mostly I hate growing up, getting out of college (with degree in hand), and live-action role-playing being an adult. This world may suck the worst of all of them. Thank you al qaeda and all those groups of people not so very different from you. You make this world suck and blow at the same time.