Sunday, September 29, 2013

Has "Appendix N" Gone Retail Before Shipping to the Majority of it's Kickstarter Supporters?

Hardly a week goes by without getting an email from someone asking me if I know the current status of the Appendix N Kickstarter - everyone wants to know when they are going to get their goods, and since I got mine three months ago, I must have some inside knowledge.

Here's the simple answer - I have no inside knowledge. But I do listen and I do read.

The last update on the Appendix N Kickstarter indicated the hope to get everything to everyone before the end of the year. Which would mean some folks would be getting theirs six months after I got mine.

Nowhere did it mention that Appendix N releases were being released to the general public before getting into the hands of those that supported the Kickstarter. It's been brought to my attention that the Appendix N releases are hitting retail distribution, like NOW. Is it possible that someone miscoded an entry? Sure - but at multiple locations?

Here's the direct links:





Now, as a community, we've bitched and complained when Kickstarters have shipped to retail before landing in the hands of those that supported the project. This might be a distributor screw up - but if folks can make a purchase and receive product before those that supported the Appendix N Kickstarter (especially those that kicked in extra for shipping after the fact) then there is a real problem here.

The Paizo link actually cost $11.01. I just ordered a set (shipping hurt but what the heck). When I get my Paizo copies, I'll post a pic. Hopefully folks will have pics of their Kickstarter copies to post before then.


  1. Hey Erik,

    You only have print copies of the first two Appendix N Modules. I promised a large number of modules in the Kickstarter and everyone has at least the pdfs for 6 or more them so far. It is our hope to get all of the rest of the printed modules to folks before the end of the year. Since the first batch of modules (#1 & #2 - like you have) went out to some of the highest levels of supporters, I have changed the modules a bit to help give even more value to the kickstarter supporters.

    All of the Kickstarter versions of the Appendix N Adventure modules are now limited edition with twice as much art & player’s handouts, with a second, higher-level version of the module and two more, short add-on modules. They were designed to be much better than the retail versions to help the kickstarter supporters. We For example, Appendix N Adventures #1: “The Ruins of Ramat” kickstarter version now includes the original zero-level funnel, a 3rd level version with a number of new monsters, two add-on adventures, two maps and six player’s handouts. That’s a pretty substantial expansion. We are almost ready to start shipping this one out to all supporters.

    The retail version of these first two Appendix N Adventure modules are just the two modules with has far fewer art and player handouts - an no add-on adventures at all.

    But the bottom line is we honestly thought we had most of October to get the first of the limited edition kickstarter modules out to supporters before the smaller retail versions would hit game stores. With all that I have put folks through with this kickstarter, I was hoping to surprise supporters with all of the expanded material as it arrived in the mail.

    I wish we would have waited another month before sending them to distribution, but I have been trying to get everything caught up with BHP and I should have delayed my obligation to my distributor until all the kickstarter supporters had their print copies. Doing one more thing to upset folks is not what I am trying to do.

    I will make sure it does not happen again. I am sorry for this betrayal of your trust and support. I will do my best to try and win back both.

    1. John,

      Your failure here is communication. I think your Kickstarter supporters would prefer accurate information over surprises, good or bad.

      To be honest, very few Kickstarter surprises are good...

    2. Maybe you should focus on fulfilling the basics of the Kickstarter before you focus on bonus items, silly crap like the Dagger RPG, and retailer edits of adventures we don't have yet.

      Lots of us understand the earlier shipping snafu and even paid you more money after the KS to help compensate for this. And how long does it take to hire some shipping fulfillment people? I could have them hired and shipping in a day.

  2. I for one am a lot more excited about the expanded content than I am disappointed by the timing of the things.

  3. On slightly related note, I have had Numenera in hand for a few weeks now, but I know of at least two people locally who backed the KS that say they have yet to get their copy.

  4. Tenkar, you're the main reason I jumped on the Appendix N KS bandwagon and I'm one of the guys that chipped in additional for shipping too. It's hard to comment on BHP because everyone says what a good guy he is and that it's a one man show and that it's been a tough year for him. I want to believe all this and empathize. He already has a number of people annoyed about not recieving DD box sets and I don't really want to add fuel to the fire. The thing is, I'm starting to get the feeling "that money is coming from one project to fund another, to fund something else before we can start producing the next thing". We all know what happens to the guy holding the bag at the end of the line. I'm hoping Appendix N isn't the guy at the end of the line, especially since there is no longer any talk about gaming boxes or the Dagger Screen. I hate to think how long I'll have to wait to see the gaming box if I ever see it. Ah well (sigh).

    1. I can't pick all winners ;)

      Seriously, John does good stuff - if you accept the fact that he chronically late on EVERY project he's done.

      I'm upset for the folks that supported this project, dont have anything to show for it yet and now get to see the project they supported for sale at retail stores.

      I know it's not the surprise John wanted for folks, but it's the one he gave them...

  5. The only surprises we get from John are bad ones. Let's be honest, he's been full of it. It's been one excuse after the other for the past year. The news about retail having print copies before his Kickstarter backers is a new low. John's robbing Peter to pay Paul & the Kickstarter backers are the suckers still left with no print modules. The only person I know to receive print copies is Erik Tenkar, perhaps John sent them out to make it appear as if the print copies were being shipped. Nothing surprises me about John Adams anymore. I wonder if Joseph Goodman wishes he'd never given the DCC license to Brave Halfling.

  6. I just hope that the Brave Halfling fans & bloggers stop promoting the Brave Halfling product or any of their future Kickstarters. I don't want more DCC fans getting let down by false promises. I've learnt a valuable lesson & I'm now very selective about where I place my Kickstarter money.

  7. Same thing happened with Traveller 5, folks were not impressed.

  8. Eric, so I have a feeling that the two print modules that you got are not the Kickstarter modules, but copies of these two retail release versions.

    Which would imply that they were sent to you to review with regard to this retail release, and are not any fulfillment of your KS.

  9. >> everyone has at least the pdfs for 6 or more them so far <<

    That's just not true, I'm afraid. I have had PDFs for modules #1 - #4.

    As for print versions I have seen nothing, although I did receive an email on 28th March saying "I am prepping the first supporters print shipment and I want to make sure I have your current shipping address."

    I have pretty much given up any hope of ever seeing what I signed up for in hard copy form. At least it was only $31 but I do feel suckered that I was one of the ones that paid the additional postage (even though I was also one of the ones that warned John he wasn't charging enough to cover postage while the KS was still running).

    I suspect John has to sell some copies through retail to fund the dispatch of the others to the KS backers.

    Up to now, I've always been one of the ones saying "John is a nice guy and he had a rough time earlier in the year" but from where I'm standing I can now see the first signs of deliberate deceit.

    1. Just to clarify, I do not think the original intent was to deceive, I think the situation BHP has ended up in is down to stupidity / naiivete / inexperience / call it what you will rather than malice. However, it would seem that we are now seeing deceit to cover up that stupidity. Unfortunately I suspect the KS money is long gone.


Tenkar's Tavern is supported by various affiliate programs, including Amazon, RPGNow,
and Humble Bundle as well as Patreon. Your patronage is appreciated and helps keep the
lights on and the taps flowing. Your Humble Bartender, Tenkar

Blogs of Inspiration & Erudition